1904 Allegheny Game Cards

[Jay Wolt]

I would love some consistency as well and believe all hand cut cards
should just be slabbed as authentic. In the case of Bazooka panels or
strip cards the cards share the dotted or solid line barrier, so if you cut the first
card that has the dotted lines and show all 4 lines, it will get a numerical grade.
But in doing so the next card will be missing the border and will only receive
an authentic designation, which is kinda crazy that 2 consecutive cards will
have different criteria for grading.

[barrysloate]

I believe the criteria used for grading hand cut cuts is the size of the borders. If the handcutting is done neatly, with four relatively full borders, then the card is eligible for a numerical grade. If it's cut so close that it goes nearly into the image, it will get an AUTH grade. I feel this can get too subjective but that's the way I am told it works.

I should add I pretty much repeated what Jay just said.

[MacDice]

Does anyone know if they ever created a reprint set? Everything else seems to have been reprinted at some time. Since I will probably never get the card that I want in the set, would settle for a reprint...

[Leon]

Originally Posted by MacDice

Does anyone know if they ever created a reprint set? Everything else seems to have been reprinted at some time. Since I will probably never get the card that I want in the set, would settle for a reprint...

I have never seen a reprint of an Allegheny card but that doesn't mean they don't exist. You might check Frisch, they seem to have reprints of a lot of sets.