not Fred Dunlap at Heritage

[prewarsports]

Didn't Fred Dunlap die before Horner starting taking Sports Photos anyways?

[tedzan]

Carl Horner is noted for his photos Circa 1900 - whenever.

Fred Dunlap died in 1902.






TED Z

[bmarlowe1]

Originally Posted by prewarsports

Didn't Fred Dunlap die before Horner starting taking Sports Photos anyways?

My "Portrait of Baseball Photography" by Marshall Fogel is hiding somewhere in my house. That is a good source for that info. Goodwin pegs his BB photos from 1905-1910. In any case, I think the Heritage claim of c1890 is way too early for Horner BB photos.

[Bicem]

The Pop Dillon Horner cabinet I owned showed him in a Tigers uniform, he played for Detroit in 1901 and most of 1902 before heading to Baltimore.

[bmarlowe1]

Heritage has removed the photo.

I should add that they (or their consignor) did a nice job researching lot #81174

http://sports.ha.com/common/view_ite...8&Lot_No=81174

They correctly list all 12 individuals depicted, though they don't specify the bottom 3, who by process of elimination must be Sensendorfer, Reach and Murnane - but in what order?

[Baseball Rarities]

Originally Posted by bmarlowe1

Heritage has removed the photo.

I should add that they (or their consignor) did a nice job researching lot #81174

http://sports.ha.com/common/view_ite...8&Lot_No=81174

They correctly list all 12 individuals depicted, though they don't specify the bottom 3, who by process of elimination must be Sensendorfer, Reach and Murnane - but in what order?

Sensendorfer - Murnane - Reach

[barrysloate]

Wouldn't it be nice if Heritage took a moment to mention that all 12 cabinets are badly trimmed? That wasn't even mentioned in the description. That said, of course this is a very significant find.

[prewarsports]

Not that it matters because the photo was clearly not Dunlap, but Fred Dunlap was a homeless vagrant for the last years of his life and certainly did not have a penny to spend on anything but alcohol after about 1895.