A Fantasy Poll for Old Judge Collectors

[Steve D]

I was leaning toward the cabinets, but the fact that this choice leaves four HOFers missing, led me to pick the 495 different cards.

I'd keep the HOFers, Dummy Hoy, California Brown and (I can't think of his name, but the player who went on to be an umpire and was considered for the HOF last year), and sell/trade the rest for other HOF N172s and N173s

Steve

[yomass]

The cabinets are the obvious choice for me.
And a large Gypsy Queen to boot!
This would get you an image of almost all the top players of the era in a format that is ideal for viewing detail.

[Cat]

Anson in uniform

[brianp-beme]

Quantity means 'a lot' to me.

Brian

[slidekellyslide]

I went with the four nine five.

[Bicem]

cabinets - would be a sweet collection.

[3-2-count]

I chose the 495 different subjects with the cabinets taking the second spot.