Not to bash PSA but........

[T206DK]

I think I've seen a PSA graded Dorgan that had an suspicious looking back. It was smooth and shiny if I remember correctly. It wasn't mine though

[E93]

Shiny is a good sign. Skinned N172s don't have that original luster any more.
JimB

[slidekellyslide]

I've never seen a skinned N172 in a PSA holder. Got a pic of one?

[kcohen]

Do you mean holdered as authentic or given a numerical grade? BTW, how ya doin'?

Ken

[slidekellyslide]

I'm pretty sure the only legitimate company that will encapsulate skinned OJ's is Becket. I don't think PSA will even give an A to a skinned OJ.

[Matt]

Toby - nice to see you posting in the forum - do you have a scan of what you are referring to?

[bigfish]

Ken, doing well. Hope we can catch up at the national. I do not have scans. The backs should be smooth looking. Skinned backs have a darker rough surface look to them. I was burned on a harry wright and just wanted folks to be aware. Ask for back scans if you are paying decent money for a psa graded old judge. Sgc does not make this mistake