let me get this straight...

[terjung]

Originally Posted by FUBAR

before i came to this site, Beckett was the only grading company whose slabs i would buy. I was very surprised no one here supported them.

From my experience, they have always graded very tough and have yet to see an over grade, although i am sure they do exist.

I have since learned/ noticed from the much more experienced and knowledgable guys that SGC is acceptable and PSA is ok as long at you dont buy from Jose Hernandez, or anyone else selling high end cards in the LA area

Personally Beckett grading has always been favorable.

It depends what era's cards you are talking about. I always bought BGS for modern stuff. Since I shifted gears to prewar collecting, however, BGS (BVG) doesn't hold a candle to SGC, imo. Depending on the issue, PSA may be acceptable, but I am far and away most comfortable buying SGC slabs for my prewar cards. It is a personal choice though and one that each collector needs to make for himself (or herself).

As far as Beckettmedia selling BGS graded cards, I can certainly see how the conflict of interest (whether real or only perceived due to company structure) is there. On one hand, I prefer that they are at least out there under their own name so that we don't have a "did you know that so-and-so works for Beckett and is selling their cards" type expose. On the other hand, I guess I wouldn't expect for them to sell PSA-slabbed cards. Since I largely don't collect modern cards any more, Beckett is pretty much a moot point to me since I avoid them.

[Leon]

Beckett is an advertiser and I know some of the guys personally. That being said I trust BVG very much and have never had an issue with their grading (since they bought back one high profile mistake, Cobb-Drum)....I actually trust their grading far more than PSA......but that is just my opinion. PSA does a decent job (I am sure a few PSA bigots will need to chime in, in order to protect their slabs). I am just giving my personal opinion here. As for Beckettmedia selling on Ebay...it's hard to get passed that perception of a conflict, though I don't have an issue with it. I pay as much as I want to for any given card, regardless of the seller or slab. ....regards

[Robextend]

Originally Posted by Leon

I pay as much as I want to for any given card, regardless of the seller or slab. ....regards

Amen, could not have said it better...

[T206DK]

In the end , a card is only worth what we as collectors are willing to pay for it.

[tbob]

I'll echo Jim's comment: you can pick up some really sharp pre-war cards on ebay in BVG holders which look better than their similarly graded PSA and SGC counterparts and at a much better price. I have crossed over BVG caramels to SGC and received a bump every time but once.
(Added to state that I cracked the cards out and submitted them raw).

[teetwoohsix]

I think,from what I've seen,that BVG does a pretty good job.The T206's I have that are graded by BVG seem very accurate-maybe a little on the "tight" side even,which IMO,is better than "overgraded".

I don't go for anything graded by BCCG,on the other hand.Seems bunk,and I feel they should do away with it(I know,they bank off it,so they won't).

I have the most confidence in SGC,BVG second,and PSA last.PSA seems to be all over the place in the V/G-V/g-EX range..............

Regards,Clayton