who has the nicest signature?

[canjond]

I always like Ted William's signature as well.

In terms of vintage players, I always felt Mays and Yaz both had horrible looking signatures.

[bigtrain]

Although I like Gehringer's signature, to me it looks too mechanical, like he was doing a penmanship exercise. For consistency and legibility I nominate Harmon Killebrew.

[Robextend]

Duke Snider's signature is pretty good and I think has been pretty consistent throughout the years.

[Orioles1954]

I really like Babe Ruth's script.

[jb217676]

I like the signatures of Mickey Mantle, Satchel Paige and Jackie Robinson.
For current players, Derek Jeter and early Ken Griffey Jr. autographs.

[perezfan]

I agree... Killebrew and Gehringer are two of the best.

I also like Ted Williams, Johnny Bench, Eddie Collins and Chas. Comiskey

Most childlike/worst of the worst are Cy Young, Buck Leonard and Brooks Robinson (yuck) I think Brooksie may have actually devalued a few photos, jerseys and caps when he signed them!

[dwr11]

I would have to go with Harmon Killebrew. Not only a consistent and legible autograph but a class act as well.

[jb217676]

How could I forget the signature of Sandy Koufax! One of the all-time best autographs!

[base_ball]

Greg Marino, hands down, er, up.

[pgellis]

I really like Cal Ripken's autograph. Clean, artistic, nice.

I agree Brooks Robinson's is awful. It almost wraps around an entire baseball.

[Scott Garner]

My votes are:
Pre-war: Christy Mathewson, "Chief" Bender, Walter Johnson
Post-war: Ted Williams, Joe D, Steve Carlton