If you had a choice to make.........

[Jacklitsch]

yes and no

I consider the set "complete" without the big 4

[collectbaseball]

I'd definitely take Wagner!!! It might not be as rare, but it's one of the most recognizable and awesome (in both senses of the word) cards around. Then, I'd drop $300 on a nice Doyle N.Y. - it's close enough for me.

[Mark]

I would take the Wagner because it would enable me to complete my Pirates team subset in t206.