C46 O'Hara vs. M116 O'Hara

[Archive]

Posted By: Richard

Bill,

Valid point -- I did swing by your site prior to my initial post to compare the T204 to the M116. I did not realize it was a Horner photo.

What has me leaning towards the C46 was that the other O'Hara cards I looked at (T206, E92/E101) look more like the C46 O'Hara than the M116 O'Hara. The 1912 team photo, which I will post later, also looks much more like the C46. Since that makes up four different poses (potentially from different sources), I figured it was more likely that the T204 was labeled in error (and then used by Sporting Life 'in error'), than for every other O'Hara to be incorrect.

Of course, it's all speculation -- and maybe you're on to something with suggesting that they are just different O'Hara's.

We'll see what I can dig up.

Thanks!

Richard.