Posted By:
PCJosh -- the post above that was edited said all the other sales allowed PayPal, but not this one. I went and looked at the seller's completed auctions ... only one, and he took PayPal for that.
I was assuming there were numerous other PayPal auctions, but given the seller's response, the fact that the only other auction he ran had PayPal (not a cheap item either), and what PSA said about the holder, I would have been in contact with the police already.
Certainly not enough to convict the guy, but there's enough indicia of foul play here to justify Tony starting to make the seller's life difficult, and to get his money back.