My two-cents on "The Card"...boy did I enjoy it

[Archive]

Posted By: Mark Evans

I enjoyed the book and think that, while flawed, it makes a contribution to the hobby because it details the history of the Wagner card, I assume for the first time in a mainstream publication. I also assume the story to be true, in essence, at least until someone involved provides a contradictory account in a public forum.

The other information provided -- a brief history of cards, grading services, sports memorabilia auctions, and Honus himself -- likely appears elsewhere but is worthy of inclusion in this book, in my view, as it puts the story in context.

The significant downside of the book, in my opinion, is its underlying theme that fraud pervades the hobby. This strikes me as overstated for dramatic effect. Also, the authors' support for the Cobb/Edwards card appears ill-informed and misguided.

Finally, the authors appear to respect the expertise of this Board, which is mentioned numerous times and makes me think I'm not totally wasting my time in lurking.

Hope to see all at the National. Mark