Posted By:
FYSSGC is the best overall choice.
SGC Positives:
1. No club to join.
2. Better grading rates.
3. Half grades.
4. Better aesthics for holder.
5. More consistent grading.
6. Guarantee.
7. Better customer service.
PSA Positives:
1. Better registry.
2. More for sale on any given day in the market.
For me, the SGC positives far outweigh the PSA positives. In my opinion, the SGC positives have much more real value and integrity. Also, it is not a big deal to me personally that the PSA registry is better than the SGC registry. They both accomplish the same thing. Also, there are more SGC T206's available than I can afford, so it really does not matter that there are even more PSA T206's out there at one time that I can not afford.
For others, the PSA positives are much more important for them personally and it makes it an easy decision for them also.
In any case, take in the input and make your own informed decision based on what you personally view as important.