Let's again debate Cobb's real 1st card ?

[Archive]

Posted By: Josh K.

Ted,

I think you are improperly laying blame on the grading companies. SGC no longer dates e102s as being from 1908 - that cobb above was obviously holdered several years ago when lemke's guide (or whatever guide they go by) dated those cards as being from 1908. I dont think there is any disagreement as to the 1910 date for the e102s. The problem is that old slabs still exist with the old, no longer accepted, date. There is nothing the grading companies can do about that unless those cards are submitted for a reholder.