Scenario~Your Opinions

[Archive]

Posted By: dennis

if trimming or card being short is stated in the discription my opinion is that it will not be graded.IT IS SHORT. (my thinking is it has already been rejected,maybe numerous times by different graders)that said,i would decide to bid on card as is. 1) Did the auctioneer act unethically at any point? yes he should have just replied that there was no refunds and stopped there.
2) Did the buyer threaten him? And if so is that illegal? buyer should if unhappy w/card just sell with full disclosure.
3) If you were the buyer, what would YOU have done? sold the card w/full disclosure--but as i said earlier my thought is if "short" is mentioned in discription it is ungradeable,AND I WOULD HAVE BID ONLY ACCEPTING THIS FACT.
4) Do you have any other opinions? grading companys can be wrong too.
5) What could the buyer expect to get for the card given the rest of the card is VgEx? i've seen lots of cards get big bids w/trimmed disclosed