Re:

[Archive]

Posted By: petecld

THIS is what the original post said before editing:

__________________________________________________ ____________________________________

1909 E95 Cobb & Signed Bill Carrigan...Need help
March 23 2005 at 11:21 AM
Dave Yoken Ê (Login dyoken)

Hi everyone,

A few years back, I bought about 25 1909 E95 Philadelphia Caramels, among others,
at a small antiques auction house in Vermont.
Among them are a Ty Cobb and a Bill Carrigan that is signed by Carrigan.

I am fairly certain these are real cards, as they were found in an old album
labeled "Tobacco Cards" in an old farmhouse in Vermont. And since they were
in an album, most of the cards have tape on the corners, but are in otherwise
decent shape, as you can see by my scans below.

My questions are:

1) Do you think they are real?
2) I am looking to sell them. Are they worth anything in this condition, especially considering the tape residue on the front?
3) I have never seen a signed tobacco or caramel issue before. If this Carrigan card is authenticated, is it worth anything?
3) Should I send them in to PSA or SGC for grading?
4) Where is the best place to sell them for a decent return on my money, and would you have any idea what they might be worth?

Here are the scans, and thanks so much for all your help and advice!!!

__________________________________________________ ____________________________________


He then posted images used from the fobailey site.