Herpolsheimer's part 2

[Archive]

Posted By: Todd (nolemmings)

that these auctions are all private, especially since the Seller sells so many items and only these cards appear to be private sales.

I'd be interested to see what SGC says. I am also skeptical of grading companies, but if they found it to be no good, I'd probably pass on any of these. Finally, as to the poster who says he was told by a dealer selling them years ago that they were fake, I too wonder why such comment would be made if untrue. Maybe the ones on Ebay are real and the ones he was selling were reprints of those, but the whole thing still seems strange.