My SGC pain…. Only a 5.5??

[Elberson]

We should start a go fund me so you can send it to PSA next

[jtq81]

That's as good, or better, than my SGC 7.

When was this graded? Are we already seeing the effects of Nat Turner poaching SGC graders and bringing them over to PSA?

[tjisonline]

Originally Posted by jtq81

That's as good, or better, than my SGC 7.

When was this graded? Are we already seeing the effects of Nat Turner poaching SGC graders and bringing them over to PSA?

Not Nat but Hoge and Reza. I also have been seeing it since after the 2024 National. Nat is just doing what’s best for Collector's as a whole. I put far more on Hoge.

That is a mighty fine SGC graded Pete Rose. I have a SGC 6 graded Rose recently that PSA bulked at crossing over to a 6. Recent SGC grade also by the previous owner. Well after the acquisition. So laughable and frustrating.

[Kutcher55]

It's really pointless to evaluate a card off a single on line photo. The Rose has nice eye appeal but probably has a small surface issue that caused the downgrade to a 5.5.