Dog's Head and Old Judge Cabinet value?

[nberger9]

Thank you all for your very kind words and informative replies. I very much appreciate it and I've recently started re-investing in the hobby.

Although this is 19th century baseball, i am on the hunt for a 1951 Mantle in PSA 6 if anyone has one looking to sell. I also own 75 of the 1958 Pele Alifabologet rookie cards. I'm always on the hunt for those if anyone knows of any leads regarding private sales.

Thanks again and I look forward to being a valued member of this community.

Neal

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by nberger9

Thank you all for your very kind words and informative replies. I very much appreciate it and I've recently started re-investing in the hobby.

Although this is 19th century baseball, i am on the hunt for a 1951 Mantle in PSA 6 if anyone has one looking to sell. I also own 75 of the 1958 Pele Alifabologet rookie cards. I'm always on the hunt for those if anyone knows of any leads regarding private sales.

Thanks again and I look forward to being a valued member of this community.

Neal

75 peles!!!!!!!!! you hoarder you!!!!!

[Brent G.]

Originally Posted by nberger9

Thank you all for your very kind words and informative replies. I very much appreciate it and I've recently started re-investing in the hobby.

Although this is 19th century baseball, i am on the hunt for a 1951 Mantle in PSA 6 if anyone has one looking to sell. I also own 75 of the 1958 Pele Alifabologet rookie cards. I'm always on the hunt for those if anyone knows of any leads regarding private sales.

Thanks again and I look forward to being a valued member of this community.

Neal

In case you didn't see this '51 Mantle PSA 6: https://goldin.co/item/1951-bowman-2...JkSW5kZXgiOjl9

[nberger9]

Originally Posted by Brent G.

In case you didn't see this '51 Mantle PSA 6: https://goldin.co/item/1951-bowman-2...JkSW5kZXgiOjl9

Thank you very much, Brent. I'm not sure how i missed that one so thank you very much for alerting me. The bids are already pretty high with 3 days to go. I think under $40k all-in is probably a fair price but we shall see.

Thanks again!

Neal

[oldjudge]

Hi Neal--very nice image on the DH Ward! I wonder why it only got a 2.5--is there a back issue? It's such a thin market that it is tough to accurately value a card like that. Based on scarcity and appearance you would think it is worth more than $10k, but I wouldn't be shocked if it went for a little less at auction or if it went for $20K. Since you are not selling it, it doesn't really matter. We picture some other DH cabinets of Hall of Famers in the Old Judge book.

[puckpaul]

well, might as well chime in with my Dogs Head. Only one i have, and its image isnt nearly as nice.

[nberger9]

Originally Posted by puckpaul

well, might as well chime in with my Dogs Head. Only one i have, and its image isnt nearly as nice.

Very cool! I wonder how many in total are out there?

[molenick]

Love the Ward. I have this one.

[nberger9]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

Hi Neal--very nice image on the DH Ward! I wonder why it only got a 2.5--is there a back issue? It's such a thin market that it is tough to accurately value a card like that. Based on scarcity and appearance you would think it is worth more than $10k, but I wouldn't be shocked if it went for a little less at auction or if it went for $20K. Since you are not selling it, it doesn't really matter. We picture some other DH cabinets of Hall of Famers in the Old Judge book.

Thank you very much for your kind reply. There is no back issue and maybe i'll consider resubmitting it as I agree that the grade seems low.

Thanks again!

Neal