Prompt Advice Needed!

[bnorth]

I agree with others that SGC got them correct or at least more correct than your guesses. As collectors we tend to highly over grade our own cards and slightly undergrade other peoples cards.

[rand1com]

Sorry but the cards are within a half grade on all of them and you cannot expect better than that IMO.

Yes, we all think our cards are better than they actually are.

I would not resubmit any of them but if I was going to, I would break them out and submit as a new submission. The chances of them reviewing and raising the grades is zero IMO.

[Andrew1975]

Some very nice cards, and they look great in the tuxes. The grades look more or less correct to me.

[Lobo Aullando]

Originally Posted by Andrew1975

The grades look more or less correct to me.

Hell, that's probably some news right there...

[LEHR]

IMO, I'd have been thrilled with those grades.

The Waddell portrait was obviously trimmed and graded correctly. The Cy Young could have went a half grade higher, but I actually guessed the Wheat and Johnson to be 2.5's before I saw the actual grades.

Again, just my opinion.

[Fuddjcal]

Originally Posted by bnorth

I agree with others that SGC got them correct or at least more correct than your guesses. As collectors we tend to highly over grade our own cards and slightly undergrade other peoples cards.

I agree