Most undervalued HOFers

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by G1911

James' list is what he thinks about each player, with hundreds of pages written alongside his listing in numerical order of he selects over who. A list of players sorted by WAR is not the same thing and has absolutely nothing to do with James list, which his total evaluation. Stop lying.

The very reason people develop statistical analyses is because they believe that traditional subjective rankings are inadequate. So to say they don't believe the results of their analyses is senseless. Might one find isolated extreme examples where the developers would agree that their model didn't yield the right result? It's possible, any model has limitations. But your whole, oh that's just a ranking, it doesn't have anything to do with who the developers think is better schtick just makes no logical sense at all.