Greg Morris and grading companies

[BigfootIsReal]

GM is a COMPLETE joke! I bought twelve RAW cards from him within the last year. Eight of the twelve came back from PSA ONE or more grades BELOW what GM said. One other came back as "trimmed". I returned three which he gave me a refund and also refunded the trimmed one. Gave some negative feedback and said the graders need to slow down. What did they do next? They deleted my comment and blocked me from their website!

I fell into the trap of paying pretty much graded prices for raw, don't any of you do the same.

[Johnny630]

Originally Posted by BigfootIsReal

GM is a COMPLETE joke! I bought twelve RAW cards from him within the last year. Eight of the twelve came back from PSA ONE or more grades BELOW what GM said. One other came back as "trimmed". I returned three which he gave me a refund and also refunded the trimmed one. Gave some negative feedback and said the graders need to slow down. What did they do next? They deleted my comment and blocked me from their website!

I fell into the trap of paying pretty much graded prices for raw, don't any of you do the same.

Why did you return them back if they graded lower than he said and expect a refund? The only one really had to give you a refund was the one that came back trimmed. Couldn’t imagine being a seller or selling something raw, and the card greeting lower than I said, but still receiving a number grade and the person demanding a refund/return. That seems a little messed up.

[Peter_Spaeth]

It's a well known phenomenon that PSA can grade vintage cards a grade or even two too low. It's either the way they want to do things, or just that graders used to pack fresh chrome stuff don't know how to grade vintage. So if Morris grades by the usual criteria, PSA is not necessarily going to agree.

[ALBB]

just wish his shipping cost was a tad less

[Eric72]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

It's a well known phenomenon that PSA can grade vintage cards a grade or even two too low. It's either the way they want to do things, or just that graders used to pack fresh chrome stuff don't know how to grade vintage. So if Morris grades by the usual criteria, PSA is not necessarily going to agree.

This

[Bigdaddy]

Originally Posted by Johnny630

Why did you return them back if they graded lower than he said and expect a refund? The only one really had to give you a refund was the one that came back trimmed. Couldn’t imagine being a seller or selling something raw, and the card greeting lower than I said, but still receiving a number grade and the person demanding a refund/return. That seems a little messed up.

+1, however I think 'a little' is an understatement.

[Exhibitman]

I am shocked at the prices GM gets on raw cards. Pleased too: I buy someone else's cards and feel like I am getting bargains every time

[Republicaninmass]

Me thinks it would be prudent, since gm sells it's own cards as well as consignments, to grade anything worth grading and auction via gmcards2 or the new graded card selling account.

[parkplace33]

So from reading the responses, I guess GM does not have an affiliation with a grading card company.

That is strange to me , especially with all the recent buy outs. Maybe they will soon? or even start their own company?

[timn1]

*Edited to clarify that I have never done any business with Greg Morris either as buyer or consignor.*

Seems to me that gm does a lot of Topps era set breakups, and obviously most of those cards will be bought by other set collectors. Most set collectors, except for the registry types, don't want to have to mess with graded cards. Who wants to have to pay for and store 598 graded cards, most of which are worth less than the cost of grading?

So Morris has developed a sensible model where he tries to assign raw cards grades that will be generally accurate. Many people find them accurate enough that they buy from him repeatedly, therefore he is successful. It's not rocket science, just a sensible market niche and business model.

To the guy who said Morris is a joke: Like some others have said in this thread, I am amazed that any dealer would give a refund under the conditions you described (except the card that graded trimmed). And if I were that dealer and did give those refunds, you can bet that i would ban that customer from that point, as not worth the hassle. What you asked for, and your comment in this thread, were totally unreasonable. Guarantees of authenticity are fine, but if you want a guarantee that a card will achieve a certain number grade from a TPG, you have to buy it already slabbed in that grade!

[Yoda]

Originally Posted by BigfootIsReal

GM is a COMPLETE joke! I bought twelve RAW cards from him within the last year. Eight of the twelve came back from PSA ONE or more grades BELOW what GM said. One other came back as "trimmed". I returned three which he gave me a refund and also refunded the trimmed one. Gave some negative feedback and said the graders need to slow down. What did they do next? They deleted my comment and blocked me from their website!

I fell into the trap of paying pretty much graded prices for raw, don't any of you do the same.

Rock, join the Club of Being Barred from Gm. I left what I thought was a mild comment here on the Board about his grading standards slipping somewhat. Took about 2 days to be banned. He obviously is a little touchy about the subject.

[Snowman]

Originally Posted by BigfootIsReal

GM is a COMPLETE joke! I bought twelve RAW cards from him within the last year. Eight of the twelve came back from PSA ONE or more grades BELOW what GM said. One other came back as "trimmed". I returned three which he gave me a refund and also refunded the trimmed one. Gave some negative feedback and said the graders need to slow down. What did they do next? They deleted my comment and blocked me from their website!

I fell into the trap of paying pretty much graded prices for raw, don't any of you do the same.

What is your ebay username?

[Snowman]

Greg Morris's grades are not the problem. The problem is PSA's moving of their own goal posts.

[Bigdaddy]

Originally Posted by Snowman

Greg Morris's grades are not the problem. The problem is PSA's moving of their own goal posts.

None of the grading standards utilized by any of the grading companies are written in stone or even widely accepted by a industry standards association. That's kind of a problem, at least for us.

[timn1]

Originally Posted by Snowman

What is your ebay username?

A pre-emptive strike might save a bit o' trouble in the long run?