1910 Punch Cobb with backing - New Discovery??

[aljurgela]

And it does not have the original back... Here is a Punch card with a back (though the backs have varying degrees of size)...

[e107collector]

Originally Posted by aljurgela

And it does not have the original back... Here is a Punch card with a back (though the backs have varying degrees of size)...

Al,

Just curious, but does that Luis Padron card you have pictured, have the same "Punch" advertising back that Cubanball posted above?

Thanks.

[aljurgela]

Originally Posted by e107collector

Al,

Just curious, but does that Luis Padron card you have pictured, have the same "Punch" advertising back that Cubanball posted above?

Thanks.

Here are the ones that I have....

[e107collector]

Al,

Kudos to you for putting that collection together as much as you did already. It's so hard when most the the cards only have an example or two known to exist.



If PSA did indeed grade this card, I would have to think it would have been shown on their population registry now, correct?

If it was a lower tier grading company, I would hope it's not a "Frankencard" that made it's way into a slab.

[aljurgela]

Originally Posted by e107collector

Al,

Kudos to you for putting that collection together as much as you did already. It's so hard when most the the cards only have an example or two known to exist.



If PSA did indeed grade this card, I would have to think it would have been shown on their population registry now, correct?

If it was a lower tier grading company, I would hope it's not a "Frakencard" that made it's way into a slab.

Has been tough for sure and just missed adding a couple this weekend in Al's LOTG auctions (I hate that double overtime closing method that makes me lose items as 3AM)... anyway... still making progress... maybe I will finish in the next couple of decades... definitely a game of patience ... both fun and frustrating at different times... but I just LOVE this set

[aljurgela]

One this about the Punch cards is the AMAZING photography (and in particular the clarity of the images on a photographic paper)...

Here is my current progress on the set on the PSA side:

https://www.psacard.com/psasetregist...shedset/403520

The above Cobb looks like a copy to me given my experience with these cards.

[MuncieNolePAZ]

Originally Posted by aljurgela

One this about the Punch cards is the AMAZING photography (and in particular the clarity of the images on a photographic paper)...

Here is my current progress on the set on the PSA side:

https://www.psacard.com/psasetregist...shedset/403520

The above Cobb looks like a copy to me given my experience with these cards.

I was hoping you would join this thread Al.

Chad

[sb1]

it's fairly obvious that the fake card has used the image from Al's card and printed/glued it on the backing, which is also most likely a copy.