HELP: Player identification

[Bucs9]

Cliff,
Doesn't look like Clarke to me.

[Bucs9]

My guesses were: L to R

Leever, Ganley, Gibson, ? , Ritchey, Wills of Phillippe, Wagner

[Scott Garner]

2nd from the left in the photo is Deacon Phillipe

[Cliff Bowman]

Originally Posted by Bucs9

My guesses were: L to R

Leever, Ganley, Gibson, ? , Ritchey, Wills of Phillippe, Wagner

I'm with you on #2 being Ganley, poor guy wasn't much to look at. He was 5'7".

[Cliff Bowman]

Originally Posted by Bucs9

My guesses were: L to R

Leever, Ganley, Gibson, ? , Ritchey, Wills of Phillippe, Wagner

I'm with you on #5 being Ritchey, I think that one is a slam dunk. He was 5'6".

[Cliff Bowman]

Originally Posted by Bucs9

My guesses were: L to R

Leever, Ganley, Gibson, ? , Ritchey, Wills of Phillippe, Wagner

#6 is a little taller than Wagner (5'11"), I narrowed it down to Phillippe (6'0") or Willis (6'2"), I just thought it resembled Phillippe more. Phillippe is the second photo and Willis is the third photo. ETA now I can't decide which one it is.

[Scott Garner]

Originally Posted by Cliff Bowman

#6 is a little taller than Wagner (5'11"), I narrowed it down to Phillippe (6'0") or Willis (6'2"), I just thought it resembled Phillippe more. Phillippe is the second photo and Willis is the third photo. ETA after putting the photos side by side I now think it's Willis.

I stand corrected. I believe you have Phillipe correctly identified, 2nd from right in the picture.
Nice detective work!

[Cliff Bowman]

Here are a couple more each of Phillippe and Willis, the first two are Phillippe and next two are Willis.

[Cliff Bowman]

I have to go with Vic Willis.

[bjerome]

I have to go with Willis. Three things stand out to me. The first shape of the mouth and narrowness of it. Second is the way the light glistens off the upper point of the ear when he's looking to his left or our right and third is his pointy nose.

[Cliff Bowman]

Originally Posted by Bucs9

My guesses were: L to R

Leever, Ganley, Gibson, ? , Ritchey, Wills of Phillippe, Wagner

As soon as I saw a picture of Joe Nealon I thought it was a match for #4 in black. Nealon was 6'1" and has a brutal story in what happened in the next couple of years after the photo was taken.

[Cliff Bowman]

Originally Posted by Bucs9

My guesses were: L to R

Leever, Ganley, Gibson, ? , Ritchey, Wills of Phillippe, Wagner

I couldn't make a guess on #3, I think you nailed it on Gibson (5'11")

[Cliff Bowman]

Originally Posted by Bucs9

My guesses were: L to R

Leever, Ganley, Gibson, ? , Ritchey, Wills of Phillippe, Wagner

#1 is on the left, Leever (5'11") is on the right. I think you're right it's Leever.

[lumberjack]

I really don't think the third guy from the left is Gibson. The others...dead on IMO.