Crossover Experience - Old SGC to PSA

[Snowman]

Originally Posted by raulus

This must be a newer policy. I've submitted a handful of cracked or broken PSA slabs in the past (probably around 2018/2019), and they've always come back from PSA at the same grade.

So either I got lucky, or this is a new policy. Or maybe it's a policy that they don't always apply, because erratic application of policies seems to be one of the most endearing features when it comes to the TPGs.

The odds are that they will come back in the same grade if the slabs are cracked because the card probably didn't get damaged. So whatever grade you get is a reflection of how consistent they are. But they do treat damaged slabs as raw cards and have for as long as I can remember.

[ullmandds]

You must crack them and send them raw to psa. this is your only chance of a somewhat impartial result. i personally like sgc and believe they have been aeons more consistent in their grading over the years than PleaseSubmitAgain.

While Psa is being ridiculously harsh these days...I think you may be surprised at the results...maybe in a good way.

beautiful cards btw!