Do PSA slabs *really* sell for more than SGC?

[theshowandme]

Originally Posted by cgjackson222

I don't think anyone is disputing that. But I think this thread is about which TPG you should choose for grading a card. And if you can get a significantly higher grade from an SGC, you are probably better off going that route.

The title does not match the arguments being made.

If we are talking about who is more strict on vintage and pre war, it’s likely PSA

If we are talking about who commands the premium for the same card, it’s likely PSA

If we are talking about who grades more consistently, I do not know the answer. I see cards +/- 1 or more grades all the time when people crack and grade the card back and forth

If we are talking about who I would send the majority of my cards to, it’s SGC for a number of reasons (price, look, etc.)

We need to know what we are discussing lol

[cgjackson222]

Originally Posted by theshowandme

The title does not match the arguments being made.

If we are talking about who is more strict on vintage and pre war, it’s likely PSA

If we are talking about who commands the premium for the same card, it’s likely PSA

If we are talking about who grades more consistently, I do not know the answer. I see cards +/- 1 or more grades all the time when people crack and grade the card back and forth

If we are talking about who I would send the majority of my cards to, it’s SGC for a number of reasons (price, look, etc.)

We need to know what we are discussing lol

If you want to know what we are discussing, you may wish to consider reading more than the title.

[theshowandme]

Originally Posted by cgjackson222

If you want to know what we are discussing, you may wish to consider reading more than the title.

I am an American, I only read headlines!

That said, good discussion. I’ll continue to send cards to SGC like many here