What creates this price difference?

[Kutcher55]

For individual cards the market can be incredibly inefficient. There's only a few people seriously bidding on these. If a couple of people fall in love with one of the cards and not the other, then this is the result.

[Kutcher55]

But yeah also centering is better on the more expensive '8.' That said, I don't think either 8 is a particularly great example for the grade. The more expensive 8 has snow issues along with a scratch on Frank's sleeve.

[jethrod3]

Originally Posted by Kutcher55

But yeah also centering is better on the more expensive '8.' That said, I don't think either 8 is a particularly great example for the grade. The more expensive 8 has snow issues along with a scratch on Frank's sleeve.

Actually the more expensive 8 has a few more scratches (between Cincy and Redlegs and Redlegs and OF (maybe just a print line??), not to mention either another larger scratch (or surface blemish or something!!) just below and to the right of Frank's bottom shirt button.