Slabbed 1887 WS Kimball Baseball Sheet A42

[Directly]

Moved the WaterCooler Talk- Off Topics--Ill get my popcorn ready!--not trying to be vendictive, you did lose $3.00-

[bigfanNY]

Lol Pretty close to 100% of unethical sellers who say " I am done ...I am not posting to this thread any more
ever again ...end up posting. They cannot help themselves. I am sure you would like this moved. But thats not how this works.

At this point this thread still has wheels. I for one would like to see the guarantee you wrote when you traded the card you knew was N/G. And please. please post the FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS worth of Artifacts. ( I cannot help but laugh every time type Artifacts ). Readers want to know. I want to know.

Is the popcorn you are eating left over from the latest Indiana Jones movie. Or just a bag you or one of your Rat buddies found in your lair? ...so many questions so little time. And watch that hits counter it keeps going up as more and more folks tune in.

[etsmith]

I don't know anything about the card you're talking about, but numerous collectors have posted on here about PSA failing cards that they saw signed themselves. PSA is not perfect, and seems to be rejecting a lot of good autographs lately.

[bigfanNY]

Ed
Of course PSA is not perfect. I would not even have returned the card based on that alone. I gave the seller every benifit of a doubt. After It was failed I showed it to two collector / Dealers who trade in Lebron and other high end Basketball Autographed cards. Both rejected it rather quickly and one took the time to show me a few things to look at when buying a Lebron Auto. Knowing what I know now I would not buy that card today. Tom Rebert says that even the "Advanced" autograph collector that he traded it to said it did not match up with known examples.
Given that it was failed by 3 sources that all have handled Lebron Auto's before. I asked the seller to provide one independent opinion that the signature was good. You saw his response.

[Directly]

Okay Sunshine , If of any interest please check check JSA Authentication --X99060 what do you see.

P/S Any ideal which one of these three Lebron signature shown are authentic please stand up!

[bigfanNY]

Originally Posted by Directly

Okay Sunshine , If of any interest please check check JSA Authentication --X99060 what do you see.

P/S Any ideal which one of these three Lebron signature shown are authentic please stand up!

I see the same thing anyone who looks up the cert you provided a Ken Boyer
Anymore smoke and Mirrors??

[Directly]

Originally Posted by bigfanNY

I see the same thing anyone who looks up the cert you provided a Ken Boyer
Anymore smoke and Mirrors??

Correct--anyone have a clue why I provided this as evidence?