ID Help - Album of Homemade Cards, Some Real

[Casey2296]

Page 8 image 8, 21 exhibits Johnson
Page 5 image 4, R316 Kashin.
Page 4 image 14, looks like Johnny Kling, no idea of the issue.
Page 4 image 1, obviously Waners image for 33 Goudey but I've never seen the BW image.
Neat scrapbook.

[brianp-beme]

A couple of more as look at it more.

Page 1:

player 2 - image used in W517 Earnshaw

Page 2:

player 2 - image used in W517 Heilmann (page 8 also has a similar, but slightly different Heilmann photo versus this exact W517 one...I was fooled previously!)


Brian

[Jobu]

Thanks for the IDs! I added them and dug into this further tonight, adding a couple more W517s myself and adding IDs to many of the images. I also go out my loupe to look more closely at which appear to be magazine/newspaper images mounted to cardboard (that was then cut out and glued into the album) vs likely actually being a card itself. It looks like we have ID'd the potential cards apart from Page 2 #7, Page 4 #9, Page 6 #4, Page 8 #11.

[Jobu]

And now I just got Page 4 #9 as W517 Bill Terry. So this leaves

Page 2 #7
Page 6 #4
Page 8 #11 - Christy Mathewson

After looking at these three again, I think there is a good chance they are the magazine/newspaper cutouts too but are just better mounting jobs. So this would mean we have ID'd all of the cards and many of the players.

Originally Posted by Jobu

Thanks for the IDs! I added them and dug into this further tonight, adding a couple more W517s myself and adding IDs to many of the images. I also go out my loupe to look more closely at which appear to be magazine/newspaper images mounted to cardboard (that was then cut out and glued into the album) vs likely actually being a card itself. It looks like we have ID'd the potential cards apart from Page 2 #7, Page 4 #9, Page 6 #4, Page 8 #11.

[brianp-beme]

Page 6, picture 4 is not a W517 image.

Page 8, picture 11 is not likely Christy Mathewson, based upon the commonly seen bending over infielder pose instead of a pitching pose.

Page 8, picture 16 appears to be a photo taken in the same photo session (notice differences of his body positioning against the same wall advertising backdrop) as the image used for Heilmann in the W517 set.


And for some player identifications/corrections:

Page 2, picture 6 - Traynor

Page 2, picture 13 - Goslin (mistakenly identified as 2-14. Also only 15 pictures on your listing for this page, not 16)

Page 3, picture 1 - probably not Waner

Page 3, picture 14 - W517 Lazzeri (mistakenly identified as 3-13. Also this page has 17 images, not 16)

Page 5, picture 8 - Bottomley

Page 5, picture 10 - Lefty O'Doul

Page 5, picture 12 - Cuyler?

Page 6 - missing image 16 in listing for this page.

Page 8, picture 12 - Eddie Collins


Brian - by the way, cool scrapbook and love all the different photo images of well known players. I also recognize a bunch of other players but can't put a name to the image on those.

[Casey2296]

Page 5 #7 Mel Ott?

[nolemmings]

Joe Judge is seen on page 3, #7 and again on page 6, #15.