Slabbed 1887 WS Kimball Baseball Sheet A42

[bigfanNY]

Did I use to many big words? Like I said above
I recived many similar emails from other Sellers over the past 9 years. The Key differance. ( this means the most important difference) is your card had a forged auto. Forgery means that Lebron James did not sign it. All the other transactions here on Net54 went smoothly except with you. You sold a fake auto.
I offered you the opportunity to post independent proof that the autograph is good. You so far have not.
In fact despite not having any independent proof the signature is good you sold the card again!
I have no problem continuing to post about how you sold a forgery here on Net54. In fact now that you have admitted selling the card a second time I will expand my scope and share this information on other forums where everyone appreciates when undesirable sellers are pointed out.
My hope is eventually the person who purchased your forgery the second time will hear this news. And hopefully get their money back.

[Directly]

Below is a exact copy of my email--hope this helps our readers understand I was very clear in my terms !----again I'm not going to pay the 3.00 return postage fee!--it would be good if you would leave Net54.


P/S Please Note: I can only guarantee a full refund your purchase price of 145.00 if not satisfied upon receiving the card back --if that's not agreeable I will refund your145.00 before I ship the Lebron card-- let me know before I ship the card--thanks again!

[bigfanNY]

Below is the exact Email I sent:

Payment sent.
Just to be clear there is no coa but you guarantee that the signature is authentic..correct?
Thanks
Jonathan

Why dont you post the Guarentee you gave the second time you sold this Same Card?
Now that would make for interesting reading.

[Directly]

Below is a exact copy of my email to his above question--hope this helps our readers understand I was very clear in my terms !----again I'm not going to pay the 3.00 return postage fee!--it would be good if you would leave Net54.


P/S Please Note: I can only guarantee a full refund your purchase price of 145.00 if not satisfied upon receiving the card back --if that's not agreeable I will refund your145.00 before I ship the Lebron card-- let me know before I ship the card--thanks again!

[bigfanNY]

Thank you again for replying. It gives me another opportunity to point out that the three items ( 2 you offered for sale here on Net54) fall into 3 categories.

The Fake - The Metal Sign that you knew was fake but traded it for a Comic book.
The Moldy - 1969 Topps Football Racks that you had Mold removed But did not disclose that when selling.
And The Forged. - Lebron James signature on a card. That After I returned it stating it had not passed TPG you Sold it again. STILL WAITING FOR THE GUARANTY STATMENT YOU GAVE TO THE SECOND BUYER OF THE FORGED SIGNATURE.

If anyone is in the market for any sports Memorabilia in those three Categories Fake , Moldy , Forged. Please see Tom, I am he will be happy to inject a little sunshine to your life.

[Directly]

Several buyers bought multiple's fb racks as I listed them in groups--again you don't know what your talking about as usual-you didn't buy any.

The Lebron I traded to a advanced autograph collector, he compared with others, although most Lebron autos look different--he allowed me $5,000 in trade-- now go change your diapers--LOL

I still believe Net54 would be much better off without you!--

[bigfanNY]

Wow....Just Wow... what an awesome, amazing,incredible story. Let me see if I have this stright
1- You sold me a Lebron James card with a Forged signature.
2- I submit it the PSA and they fail it.
3- I show it to a couple guys who deal in Lebron Signatures and they both say No Good in a heartbeat.
4- I contact you and say it failed authentication..you say I am not surprised.
5- I send the card back to you. It takes awhile but eventually I get my original purchase price of $145 back.
6- Then, You Tom Rebert then trade this same card, to an Advanced Autograph Collector. Who says it Doesn't look like Lebrons signature but I will give You FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS IN TRADE FOR IT.

That is such an incredible and of course 100% believable story. Why wouldn't an Advanced Lebron Collector pay you such an incredibly large amout over market value for a signature that he says doesn't match other known examples. He could go on Ebay right now and have his choice of more than 15 Differant Upper Deck pack issued Autographed cards graded by Beckett or PSA for between Two and Three Thousand Dollars. But it makes perfect sense he would overpay by Thousands of dollars for a signature he told you did not match other signatures, with no certification, it happens all the time.
I know your name is Tom Rebert but are you Tom Tom the Pipers son? Related in any way to Jack and the beanstalk? Have an uncle named Gandolf?

If your story were true I would bet the fires in a certin Missouri Trailor park would burn late into the night after you closed that deal. I know you said right here on Net54 that you have never had to steal to make a living but it sure sounds like a lucrative hobby. If your story was true.
But as I said in the begining it is a great story. A story I am going to take great pleasure in telling over and over again. Not just here but in other places were sports collectors gather to share tales of charlatans, ne'er do wells and the odd Scum bag.

[Directly]

Originally Posted by bigfanNY

Below is the exact Email I sent:

Payment sent.
Just to be clear there is no coa but you guarantee that the signature is authentic..correct?
Thanks
Jonathan

Why dont you post the Guarentee you gave the second time you sold this Same Card?
Now that would make for interesting reading.

Below is a exact copy of my email to his above question--hope this helps our readers understand I was very clear in my terms !----again I'm not going to pay the 3.00 return postage fee!--it would be good if you would leave Net54.


P/S Please Note: I can only guarantee a full refund your purchase price of 145.00 if not satisfied upon receiving the card back --if that's not agreeable I will refund your145.00 before I ship the Lebron card-- let me know before I ship the card--thanks again!