Should these 3 players be in the HOF

[GeoPoto]

I can't see putting Rose in while he is banned from baseball by baseball. Having said that, I think Manfred's position is petty, which seems to be that he was open to reinstating Rose, but only if Rose showed adequate contrition and life-style discipline. Rose, being Rose, failed to pass Manfred's test. I think Manfred should reinstate Rose for all the reasons that he was open to it in the first place, which surely includes that we have outlived the era when Rose's conduct was a threat to baseball. Then put the old man in the hall.

Sent from my motorola edge 5G UW (2021) using Tapatalk

[DPARK]

All three yes. Rose will probably get in posthumously

[obcbobd]

Over the years I've changed my mind on Bonds and Clemens and would vote for both.

Rose no

[pclpads]

Just a thot . . . wait till all three are deceased, then enshrine them. My suggestion is less controversial than enshrining them while they are still living. That's what the HOF did with Santo, who had no blemishes like these three. I guess his active HOF worthy stats got better after he retired and died.