Poll: Leaf Jackie Robinson Rookie vs Bonds Bread Rookie

[investinrookies]

3 Bond Bread portrait Jackie’s ended at auction over the last few days, you likely will never see that again.

SGC 1 eBay $4700
PSA 6 PWCC $33,600
SGC 4 Heritage $11,700

While the PSA 6 has sold higher during the peak they all still faired pretty well. The SGC 4 seems like it went for a great price? Also was watching the amount of watchers on that one and it was more than most popular prewar and postwar cards. The popularity and significance of the BB rookie appears to be growing. The numbers from this poll also show it’s preferred closer to the leaf than some would of thought.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[todeen]

Originally Posted by darwinbulldog

I'll take that bet and win. I'd pick Propagandas Montiel over Bond for Musial, but I'd also take Bond over Bowman. That of course is the less attractive Bond set, not the Jackie only Bond set, but even so, I'd rather have an earlier and rarer card than a '48 Bowman. (I have owned all 3 but no longer have any of them.) And as I've said before, Propagandas Montiel "cards" aren't cards at all, so the Bond has a good claim to being Stan Musial's rookie card if you don't count postcards either.

Originally Posted by bcbgcbrcb

I bet if a poll was offered for the Bond Musial or ‘48 Bowman, just about everyone opts for the Bowman. (Although many will prefer the Leaf, which is clearly not a rookie choice but could still be his preferred choice much as the ‘52 Topps Mantle is.

Talk about an under appreciated player. Musial's cards are worth a song compared to his peers. I picked up a graded round corner Bond Bread Musial in 2020 for almost nothing; it had paper loss on the back from a scrapbook but no damage on the front. I like the B&W and the fielding pose. But I do like the Leaf card, and one day I hope I just happen upon it and can't say no. Between the two I think I'd still choose the Bond Bread. The Leaf has too many possibilities of a misprint with the color. Sometimes I think I'm looking at 3D cards when I look at Leaf.