Auction House Etiquette, when submitting cards for grading

[x2drich2000]

My take is what does your contract with the auction house state? Was consigning a part of the agreement to get them graded?

Also, what's your relationship with this AH like? First time dealing with them or have you been a regular buyer/consignor for years? Are you consigning anything else? or is it an all or nothing?

[oldjudge]

Auction houses are in the business of running auctions, not submitting your cards for grading. They do that as a service for consignors. I'm not sure if they even have to give your cards back once consigned but if they do send them back I doubt they will ever deal with you again. Bottom line--asking for them back would be bad form unless there was a preexisting agreement concerning this.

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

Auction houses are in the business of running auctions, not submitting your cards for grading. They do that as a service for consignors. I'm not sure if they even have to give your cards back once consigned but if they do send them back I doubt they will ever deal with you again. Bottom line--asking for them back would be bad form unless there was a preexisting agreement concerning this.

This!

[notfast]

What does your contract say?

[Johnny630]

These types of questions are best if asked directly to the Auction House you're using to submit your cards for grading prior to you sending them.

[Snapolit1]

If you are crushed about the grade -- thought it would be a 7 and it comes back a 4.5 - possibly you could decide not to sell and could just reimburse AH. But best to discuss this ahead of time. I have had an AH submit stuff for me but it was always with the understanding that they were selling it. In fact pretty sure signed a consigning contract before they even submitted it.

[Orioles1954]

I work for an AH and as part of the signed contract you are obligated to sell the cards. There have been circumstances where we have made returns but those are few and far between. Changing your mind because you don’t like the grades or had a change of heart will probably spell the end of our relationship.

[Rhotchkiss]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

auction houses are in the business of running auctions, not submitting your cards for grading. They do that as a service for consignors. I'm not sure if they even have to give your cards back once consigned but if they do send them back i doubt they will ever deal with you again. Bottom line--asking for them back would be bad form unless there was a preexisting agreement concerning this.

100%

[Kenmarks]

Thanks guys for the input. Very appreciative of everyone taking the time conveying their thoughts. Just gonna let the cards proceed through the auction.

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by Kenmarks

Thanks guys for the input. Very appreciative of everyone taking the time conveying their thoughts. Just gonna let the cards proceed through the auction.

Best of luck on your results.

[Kenmarks]

Thanks guys for the input. Very appreciative of everyone taking the time conveying their thoughts. Just gonna let the cards proceed through the auction.