Merchantman Auctions in Davie FL trying to sell counterfeits Jan 27

[adeichert56]

Is there any chance he is more legit now? I am finding this thread after spending a fair amount of money. Since it was through HiBid I figured the auctioneer was legitimate. Bought some lower end mantles, other 50s and 60s that all APPEAR good to go, but now I am nervous..

Maybe not nervous that they are real, but that they could be altered, underlying issues, etc. Would love to hear if anyone has had a POSITIVE experience from buying through him. All I see are 5 good reviews through LiveAuctioneers.

[NiceDocter]

Guys like this almost never change. I would suggest submitting some of your cards to PSA or SGC to see what they say. Alternatively you could let a respected dealer with a black light , a magnifier and a good measuring device see what he thinks. A leopard does not change his spots …… I hate that people do this to an otherwise fun and enjoyable hobby. But money is a powerful character corruption for some . Good luck. Rocky Rockwell

[Exhibitman]

I'e run across a few dealers whose basic attitude is 'meh' when it comes to what they sell. They will blithely sell bad stuff mixed in with their good stuff.

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by Exhibitman

I'e run across a few dealers whose basic attitude is 'meh' when it comes to what they sell. They will blithely sell bad stuff mixed in with their good stuff.

LOL, I had one of the highly respected dealers call me names and tell me he could do anything he wanted to a card after I pointed out he had sold several altered cards as rare errors.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Originally Posted by adeichert56

Is there any chance he is more legit now? I am finding this thread after spending a fair amount of money. Since it was through HiBid I figured the auctioneer was legitimate. Bought some lower end mantles, other 50s and 60s that all APPEAR good to go, but now I am nervous..

Maybe not nervous that they are real, but that they could be altered, underlying issues, etc. Would love to hear if anyone has had a POSITIVE experience from buying through him. All I see are 5 good reviews through LiveAuctioneers.

You won't find a more knowledgeable group than right here. I would post good clear pictures and someone will spot most problems.

[JustinD]

I would have a hard time thinking that the lengthy history of that group shows they have or will sell an honest thing unless it's by mistake.