311 Mantle - which would you rather have?

[raulus]

Originally Posted by pokerplyr80

I wouldn't have spend that kind of money on either personally. I'd much rather go big for a dead centered 6.

Hopefully you could get it for under $1.4M, although Snowman might bid it up that high if it’s truly 50/50 and not merely 51/49.

[pokerplyr80]

Originally Posted by raulus

Hopefully you could get it for under $1.4M, although Snowman might bid it up that high if it’s truly 50/50 and not merely 51/49.

Ha hard to say exactly but if an off center 7 went for 468k I'd assume 350 or so for a nice centered 6. Were it not for the resale value I'd rather have a centered 6 over the 8 personally at the same price. But at this level the grade means more than eye appeal.

[puckpaul]

Sure, but just dont forget eye appeal is subjective. I much prefer the bottom card of these two yet many above insist the top looks better to them. The rich color and sharper image of the bottom card work for me.

[robw1959]

I have no preference for either card. They both look stunning to me, and in my opinion there is no discernable reason for the 5X premium.