CSG status

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by Eric72

Consider this purely hypothetical situation:

There are four identical copies of card #123 from the 1919 Super Duper Ball Card set. Same grade, same centering, etc., etc.

One is in a PSA holder, another SGC, one CSG, and one BVG. Asking prices below, and they're from the same seller...so your wheeling & dealing will amount to the same discount, if any.

PSA: $500
SGC: $450
CSG: $300
BVG: $300

Which one would you buy?

depends on the grade and POP ....lower grades with high POP to me cross over a lot easier

[Leon]

Originally Posted by 1952boyntoncollector

depends on the grade and POP ....lower grades with high POP to me cross over a lot easier

The question has nothing to do with the Pop or grades.
He specifically said it's virtually the same card.

.

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by Leon

The question has nothing to do with the Pop or grades.
He specifically said it's virtually the same card.

.

right its the same card but what is the grade and POP of the this card, i dont think its crazy to consider that as a factor of whether you can crossover the card..

Like i wouldnt think a rickey henderson BVG 10 would cross to a PSA 10, but i would take my chances that a BVG 4 (and pay less) would cross to a PSA 4 for example..doesnt mean i will be wrong or right on the cross but i did think it was a ok question to ask

[Fuddjcal]

Originally Posted by Leon

The question has nothing to do with the Pop or grades.
He specifically said it's virtually the same card.

.

Its always about the POP. Popsicle. When will my cards pop. Balloon Knot Pop. Pop goes the weasel. POP POP. I'll have another Ice cold Sody Pop. I'm gonna have some Popcorn. I felt something Pop in my neck. Hop on Pop. What's the pop. Pop Pop Pop