T206 Hoard Carolina Brights Auction is Live!

[brianp-beme]

Originally Posted by 53toppscollector

it looks short top to bottom, which may have been how it was cut at the factory.

All is hunky dory...PSA was just indicating that the card was factory altered.

Brian

[53toppscollector]

Originally Posted by brianp-beme

All is hunky dory...PSA was just indicating that the card was factory altered.

Brian

It is so exhausting, the lack of consistency and honestly, knowledge from PSA. Just like they grade the overwhelming majority of American Beauties as "miscuts" when those cards were specifically cut narrow to fit the AB packaging.

If T206 was some kind of oddball set, maybe you'd understand them not knowing every detail. But we are talking about one of the most important sets in the hobby, and one they've graded more than a quarter million cards for.

Edit > the Bres With Bat also looks short top to bottom and it too was graded A.

[NATCARD]

The original post now has a link to the site with all images of the raw N172 cards. Thanks, Jeff W

[Joe_G.]

Thanks Jeff . . . as speculated, all 1887 OJs (possible 1886 in case of Orr spotted tie). Not a single 1888, 1889, or 1890 card. Seems as though the OJs are an original collection as well from a collector who smoked OJ brand in 1887.

[Exhibitman]

Maybe he croaked before the 1888 release.

[NATCARD]

I will publish pictures as soon as I get the cards back.
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Jean Dubuc GOOD 2
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Bill Abstein VERY GOOD+ 3.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Billy Campbell VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Bill Burns VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Bill Chappelle VERY GOOD+ 3.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Josh Clark Clarke, Columbus POOR 1
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Gavvy Cravath VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Frank Delehanty Delahanty-Louisville GOOD 2
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Joe Dunn Brooklyn VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Paul Davidson GOOD+ 2.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Moose Grimshaw GOOD+ 2.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Steamer Flanagan VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Jimmy Slagle VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Harry Gasper POOR 1
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Nick Maddox VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT+ 4.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Jack White Buffalo VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Sam Strang VERY GOOD+ 3.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Ollie Pickering VERY GOOD 3
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Frank Oberlin GOOD+ 2.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Stoney McGlynn VERY GOOD 3
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Billy Nattress GOOD+ 2.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Jack Hannifan Hannifin VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Bill Lattimore POOR 1
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights John Anderson VERY GOOD+ 3.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Ira Thomas GOOD 2
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Birdie Cree VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT+ 4.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Jack Quinn VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Bill Dineen Dinneen VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Lee Quillen Quillin EXCELLENT 5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Davy Jones Detroit EXCELLENT 5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Ted Easterly VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT+ 4.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Jimmy Dygert VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT+ 4.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Lou Fiene Throwing GOOD+ 2.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Frank Arellanes POOR 1
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Jimmy Lavender VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights John Ganzel VERY GOOD+ 3.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Dots Miller Pittsburg GOOD 2
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Oscar Stanage POOR 1
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Heinie Zimmerman VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Jim Scott POOR 1
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Shad Barry Milwaukee VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT+ 4.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Owen Wilson VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Donie Bush GOOD 2
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Red Murray Batting POOR 1
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights John Titus VERY GOOD 3
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Moose McCormick GOOD 2 MC
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Chief Myers Meyers, Fielding GOOD+ 2.5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Bill Sweeney Boston VERY GOOD 3
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Hal Chase Throwing Dark Cap GOOD 2
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Jack Dunn Baltimore EXCELLENT 5
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Deacon Phillippe GOOD 2
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Fred Burchell VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4 MC
1909-11 T206 Carolina Brights Lena Blackburne VERY GOOD-EXCELLENT 4
Jeff W