M101 Ruth and CJ Jacksons in MH - Over/Under

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

All I know is I am almost positive that Gimbels jackson used to be mine. I bought it for $8500 in 2016. Traded it later to Jeff K along with a famous and Barr Jackson for his PSA 2 1914 Joe Jackson. If that gimbels is over $50k, than the FB is probably worth the same, which means hopefully my 1914 CJ is worth $100k, or it was a bad deal. And if that was the case, the 1914 CJ in MH needs to be north of $220k. I don’t think my CJ is worth $100k and I don’t think the CJ tonight goes for $220k… I should never traded my 1916 Jackson’s

Predictions:

M101 Ruth: $400k+ (same exact card apparently sold in an MH auction in December 2021 for $412k)

1914 CJ Jackson: $180k+ (could go over $200k)

As an aside, many items seem low. I expect some massive jumps in extended bidding

At the moment the prices on many cards seems soft and it could be from the Nationals, From all the Auctions at once, a combination, or it could just be that extended time will see a big jump in bids. I believe it will be the later.

Regarding the Gimbels card, Sadly for both Ryan and I he is correct and it was his, then mine, then it moved on so I could get my dream Ruth card.

The Rookie Ruth should go for over $400K
the 1915 CJ Joe Jackson PSA is trending for $325K to $350K Range
The 1914 CJ Joe Jackson SGC 4 is stronger than I thought at this point and should go for $185k to $195K (rooting for it for Ryan's CJ 2 and also for mine since I have a 2 also)
The 1916 Gimbel Joe Jackson should go for $80K
The 1915 CJ Joe Jackson PSA 3 should go for 65Kto 70K(a 3 went for $76K in April in Mile High
1922 e121 Babe Ruth Holding Ball is trending in the $35K to 40K Range

all of these prices to me would indicate a strong card market and not effected by National and many other Auctions at least as they Relate to Jackson and Ruth

[mrreality68]

Wow I am way off on most of those predictions especially the 1914 and 1915 CH Joe Jackson’s
Bidding was soft in extended time. Very surprised
Only the Ruth Rookie ended strong

[Rhotchkiss]

I took a flyer on the 1914 CJ Jackson and think I got a great deal!

I think prices were mixed- some very strong and some a little lower. I don’t think any real conclusions one way or the other can be drawn. I think we will know money once we get through REA, LOTG, Heritage and ML

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

I took a flyer on the 1914 CJ Jackson and think I got a great deal!

Nice upgrade Ryan.
Good to see some prices on other mid grade collector stuff come down a bit.

[Carter08]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

I took a flyer on the 1914 CJ Jackson and think I got a great deal!

I think prices were mixed- some very strong and some a little lower. I don’t think any real conclusions one way or the other can be drawn. I think we will know money once we get through REA, LOTG, Heritage and ML

At National the MHCC rep predicted 450. I think this was a great deal.

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by Carter08

At National the MHCC rep predicted 450. I think this was a great deal.

I do not know about it going for 450K that might just be the auction house trying to hype it up.

But I do agree I believe you got it for a great price.

Congrats on the potential deal of the day

[Jstottlemire1]

Originally Posted by mrreality68

At the moment the prices on many cards seems soft and it could be from the Nationals, From all the Auctions at once, a combination, or it could just be that extended time will see a big jump in bids. I believe it will be the later.

Regarding the Gimbels card, Sadly for both Ryan and I he is correct and it was his, then mine, then it moved on so I could get my dream Ruth card.

The Rookie Ruth should go for over $400K
the 1915 CJ Joe Jackson PSA is trending for $325K to $350K Range
The 1914 CJ Joe Jackson SGC 4 is stronger than I thought at this point and should go for $185k to $195K (rooting for it for Ryan's CJ 2 and also for mine since I have a 2 also)
The 1916 Gimbel Joe Jackson should go for $80K
The 1915 CJ Joe Jackson PSA 3 should go for 65Kto 70K(a 3 went for $76K in April in Mile High
1922 e121 Babe Ruth Holding Ball is trending in the $35K to 40K Range

all of these prices to me would indicate a strong card market and not effected by National and many other Auctions at least as they Relate to Jackson and Ruth

I anticipated the e121 ball in hand Ruth to go a bit higher as well it is a very quality copy for the grade but it still certainly went at a fair price.