Catcher impact

[packs]

Ah. I would agree with that. They also tend to spend a lot of time in organized ball one or another. Lots of time to soak it in.

[BobC]

Originally Posted by packs

Ah. I would agree with that. They also tend to spend a lot of time in organized ball one or another. Lots of time to soak it in.

Absolutely. And becasue of their interaction with the pitchers, they spend a lot more time watching and analyzing opposing team players and how they bat and so on. I doubt any other position players do anything at all like that.

[mrreality68]

interesting thread and interesting that there is no more precise way to measure catchers that are less subjective

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

One of those subjects that make the defensive knock on Piazza so frustrating. Generally pitchers liked throwing to him and he was good at blocking balls in the dirt, plays at the plate etc. He was pretty awful at throwing out base-stealers. Other than that he was not a bad defensive catcher.

[Mike D.]

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

One of those subjects that make the defensive knock on Piazza so frustrating. Generally pitchers liked throwing to him and he was good at blocking balls in the dirt, plays at the plate etc. He was pretty awful at throwing out base-stealers. Other than that he was not a bad defensive catcher.

I think that's part of what makes it so difficult...the fact that there's so many facets of the catching game - you mentioned blocking balls in the dirt and throwing out runners. Add in calling a game, ability to work with pitchers young and old, pitch framing, and more, and you've got a lot of things to measure, that take very different skill sets.

We're starting to see study in this area, which is nice compared to even the 90's, when guys who could throw out would-be base stealers won gold gloves, and those who couldn't were considered "poor defensive catchers" (your Piazza example plus say an Ivan Rodriguez).

[BobC]

Originally Posted by Mike D.

I think that's part of what makes it so difficult...the fact that there's so many facets of the catching game - you mentioned blocking balls in the dirt and throwing out runners. Add in calling a game, ability to work with pitchers young and old, pitch framing, and more, and you've got a lot of things to measure, that take very different skill sets.

We're starting to see study in this area, which is nice compared to even the 90's, when guys who could throw out would-be base stealers won gold gloves, and those who couldn't were considered "poor defensive catchers" (your Piazza example plus say an Ivan Rodriguez).

A catcher's ability to throw out someone stealing a base also has an awful lot to do with the pitcher, which a catcher can't control or really affect. The ability of many pitchers to be able to hold runners close, or the speed of their delivery and pitch they throw has probably as much, if maybe not even more, to do with the ability to throw out a someone stealing a base, than just the strength of a catcher's arm and how fast they can throw. And along with that is the ability of a pitcher to pitch from the stretch and disguise their motion so that a base runner is delayed as long as possible from being able to tell when the pitcher actually goes into their motion, and is not just getting ready to throw over to pick off the base runner.

Obviously, some catcher's had such incredible arm strength that the speed at which they could throw allowed them to throw out more runners stealing bases than other catchers. But again, a lot more of that may be on the pitcher, and the athleticism and ability of the person covering the base to react and make the tag in a timely manner as well.

There are a lot of people who put down pitchers and claim they get too much credit for wins, saying they owe a lot of it to their defensive backing and the batting prowess of their teammates. Shouldn't the same be said about catcher's as well then and their ability to throw out base runners? They are most definitely not the only player involved in throwing out someone trying to steal a base, and maybe not even the most important after all.

[Mike D.]

Originally Posted by BobC

A catcher's ability to throw out someone stealing a base also has an awful lot to do with the pitcher, which a catcher can't control or really affect. The ability of many pitchers to be able to hold runners close, or the speed of their delivery and pitch they throw has probably as much, if maybe not even more, to do with the ability to throw out a someone stealing a base, than just the strength of a catcher's arm and how fast they can throw. And along with that is the ability of a pitcher to pitch from the stretch and disguise their motion so that a base runner is delayed as long as possible from being able to tell when the pitcher actually goes into their motion, and is not just getting ready to throw over to pick off the base runner.

Obviously, some catcher's had such incredible arm strength that the speed at which they could throw allowed them to throw out more runners stealing bases than other catchers. But again, a lot more of that may be on the pitcher, and the athleticism and ability of the person covering the base to react and make the tag in a timely manner as well.

There are a lot of people who put down pitchers and claim they get too much credit for wins, saying they owe a lot of it to their defensive backing and the batting prowess of their teammates. Shouldn't the same be said about catcher's as well then and their ability to throw out base runners? They are most definitely not the only player involved in throwing out someone trying to steal a base, and maybe not even the most important after all.

Very true...really, any of the catcher metrics are somewhat pitcher dependent, including pitch framing, pitch blocking, and even game calling.

The extreme example if Doug Mirabelli. Despite being a backup, he led the league in passed balls two years in a row. That off-season, he was traded...but then re-acquired a month into the following season and even got a state police escort to the ballpark the day he was traded.

He was knuckelballer Tim Wakefield's personal catcher for several years.