Your Collecting Thoughts on Grading Companies

[GasHouseGang]

I have a mix, but I do wish they were all the same company, just to look nicer. But ultimately it's about the card, not the holder.

[Casey2296]

I like all my pre-war in sgc holders, post war looks better in Psa holders but I have a mix of both in my post war.

[Mike D.]

My spreadsheet tells me I have 810 graded cards. 809 of them are PSA. I have one Beckett...just couldn't leave it there for the price. I prefer to stick with PSA for consistency/resale value, but if the price is right, I'll buy the card not the holder for sure. In fact, I have a bid in right now on a lot of 9 graded cards from a non-PSA grading company. We'll see if the bid holds!

[rugbymarine]

I have ~125 graded cards.
- 80% PSA
- 20% SGC
- No other companies right now...not because I'm opposed to them. For what I collect (mostly 50s-70s baseball), I just don't see very many CSG and Beckett.

Like it or not, PSA is king of the market. Both in terms of number of cards out there and resale value. I don't focus on resale value, since I'm a collector-first. Any card I purchase I generally intend to own for a long time.

FWIW, I think the newer SGC holder (tuxedo) does an excellent job of presenting cards of almost any era.

[hcv123]

I have a Roberto Clemente master registry set that is all PSA (except a 1957 Salesman sample panel that I have no interest in crossing for a PSA A instead of an SGC A)
The rest of my collection is a mix of PSA and SGC and raw. Lower value cards I will usually get raw. "Keys" I will generally get graded. PSA or SGC for prewar and mostly PSA for post war (with some exceptions).

[Harliduck]

I've only flirted with graded cards in the past, and have popped more than I can count through the years. Like many here, I'm a binder raw type collector guy. I do however have a new interest in grading my 50's stars...52-56, only the oversized. Have had fun submitting. I have around 50 graded now, all SGC. I do have a couple of PSA's laying around but will either pop those or sell/trade them. Can't stand PSA's cheap looking slabs. Definitely an OCD type collector, all MUST be the same and SGC is my choice.

But to answer the question...yes, one company only here. Love the tuxedo...and not for resale value, could care less.

[JollyElm]

Open door policy for me. Bring 'em all in, as I'm fine with any and all TPG slabs. Of course, if I'm purchasing, the prices have to be in line with the respective differences in value for the big 3 or 4 TPGs.

[Mbjerry]

Originally Posted by Harliduck

I've only flirted with graded cards in the past, and have popped more than I can count through the years. Like many here, I'm a binder raw type collector guy. I do however have a new interest in grading my 50's stars...52-56, only the oversized. Have had fun submitting. I have around 50 graded now, all SGC. I do have a couple of PSA's laying around but will either pop those or sell/trade them. Can't stand PSA's cheap looking slabs. Definitely an OCD type collector, all MUST be the same and SGC is my choice.

But to answer the question...yes, one company only here. Love the tuxedo...and not for resale value, could care less.

I have also been submitting some of my own and only to SGC due to the cost. The tux has really grown on me. Now I am in a bind because some of the raw cards I have submitted to SGC I don’t want to get rid of. I’ve made some nice pickups of PSA’s that I don’t want to trade or sell. But my OCD is really acting up on the different slabs. Lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Mbjerry]

Originally Posted by hcv123

I have a Roberto Clemente master registry set that is all PSA (except a 1957 Salesman sample panel that I have no interest in crossing for a PSA A instead of an SGC A)
The rest of my collection is a mix of PSA and SGC and raw. Lower value cards I will usually get raw. "Keys" I will generally get graded. PSA or SGC for prewar and mostly PSA for post war (with some exceptions).

Here is another piece of the puzzle for me. I do like buying raw occasionally also. That adds another element. Wondering if I just want to buy graded from one company so everything is the same. But then that excludes the raw stuff which I don’t want to do either. Lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[vthobby]

Originally Posted by rugbymarine

I have ~125 graded cards.
- 80% PSA
- 20% SGC
- No other companies right now...not because I'm opposed to them. For what I collect (mostly 50s-70s baseball), I just don't see very many CSG and Beckett.

Like it or not, PSA is king of the market. Both in terms of number of cards out there and resale value. I don't focus on resale value, since I'm a collector-first. Any card I purchase I generally intend to own for a long time.

FWIW, I think the newer SGC holder (tuxedo) does an excellent job of presenting cards of almost any era.

Nice Aaron!

[DeanH3]

PSA and SGC are the two I target. I will say that CSG is growing on me. I have a few modern CSG cards and I'm very impressed with their crystal-clear holders. The new flip design is much improved over their original.

[Exhibitman]

Mine are mixed. I even have SCD (red labels), and CSG is growing on me.