What is the RAREST Pre War COMPLETE PSA graded set??

[Pat R]

Fred, I'm not sure but I think something like this is what you're looking for.
I'm not sure how rare they are maybe most people just don't get them graded.

6 cards in the set only 9 total graded by PSA one complete set and the other set has two of the 3 remaining graded cards in it.

https://www.psacard.com/pop/baseball...-comics/153905

https://www.psacard.com/psasetregist...-h804-16/16749

[whiteymet]

Originally Posted by Pat R

Fred, I'm not sure but I think something like this is what you're looking for.
I'm not sure how rare they are maybe most people just don't get them graded.

6 cards in the set only 9 total graded by PSA one complete set and the other set has two of the 3 remaining graded cards in it.

https://www.psacard.com/pop/baseball...-comics/153905

https://www.psacard.com/psasetregist...-h804-16/16749

Pat:

Bingo!! That is the type of thing I am asking about! As you say 9 cards in the complete set that is registered and only three other cards from the set in the POP report.

However there are two sets noted so far in the Post War thread that beat this. One I mentioned above, the 1954 Blossom Dairy set with only one other card in the POP and the Kiwanis Orioles set with only two other cards in the POP.

[Pat R]

Originally Posted by whiteymet

Pat:

Bingo!! That is the type of thing I am asking about! As you say 9 cards in the complete set that is registered and only three other cards from the set in the POP report.

However there are two sets noted so far in the Post War thread that beat this. One I mentioned above, the 1954 Blossom Dairy set with only one other card in the POP and the Kiwanis Orioles set with only two other cards in the POP.

This is the closest I can find Fred.

4 in the complete set with 5 total graded.

https://www.psacard.com/pop/baseball...e-cards/180609
https://www.psacard.com/psasetregist...-h804-26/20794

[terjung]

Personally, I find it difficult to postulate the question since it is limited ONLY to PSA-graded sets. Quite simply, I'm one who doesn't care about registry points. So, to me, PSA's registry is a VERY incomplete catalog of what is out there - particularly in prewar baseball.

If expanded to PSA + SGC + raw, I find it a very interesting discussion. If that is the case, once the 1 of 1 sets like Allegheny are acknowledged, I think the list would probably start and stop with Jim B's N167 set (unless Richard was able to complete his T215 Pirate set - in which case, it would likely "win").

[whiteymet]

Originally Posted by terjung

Personally, I find it difficult to postulate the question since it is limited ONLY to PSA-graded sets. Quite simply, I'm one who doesn't care about registry points. So, to me, PSA's registry is a VERY incomplete catalog of what is out there - particularly in prewar baseball.

If expanded to PSA + SGC + raw, I find it a very interesting discussion. If that is the case, once the 1 of 1 sets like Allegheny are acknowledged, I think the list would probably start and stop with Jim B's N167 set (unless Richard was able to complete his T215 Pirate set - in which case, it would likely "win").

Brian:

I agree, but HOW do you get ALL the correct info if you "expand" it to include RAW as you suggest? That is the only reason I limited it to PSA because the info is readily available

[clamendo]

Originally Posted by terjung

Personally, I find it difficult to postulate the question since it is limited ONLY to PSA-graded sets. Quite simply, I'm one who doesn't care about registry points. So, to me, PSA's registry is a VERY incomplete catalog of what is out there - particularly in prewar baseball.

If expanded to PSA + SGC + raw, I find it a very interesting discussion. If that is the case, once the 1 of 1 sets like Allegheny are acknowledged, I think the list would probably start and stop with Jim B's N167 set (unless Richard was able to complete his T215 Pirate set - in which case, it would likely "win").

If you open it to other sports, like football it would even be more interesting. I’m sure almost everyone on this forum collects others stuff.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk