Robert Edwards Auctions STILL going strong at 8:15 AM Est!!!!

[Leon]

Originally Posted by molenick

Ditto for Leon's card. Are T208s considered rarer than D359s? Or are they on about the same level?

Others might have different ideas but I would guesstimate at least 10 D359s to each T208, probably more. I have owned approx. 30 D359s over the years. I have owned about 2-3 T208s, including this one...
LL
.

[fkm_bky]

Am I in the minority that thinks the partial Wagner going for $1.8m+ was really surprising? I mean, these days nothing should surprise me, but damn…that’s a hefty sum for 2/3 of a card.

I was after a few lower end Gehrigs, but happily was out bid.

Bill

[cannonballsun]

What did that half one go for a few months ago, $470,000 ? Amazing !

[MattyC]

Liked seeing the d304 Cobb get love-- always been my favorite prewar card. Between the beauty and how scarce it is, felt it was due for a run.

[hcv123]

Originally Posted by MattyC

Liked seeing the d304 Cobb get love-- always been my favorite prewar card. Between the beauty and how scarce it is, felt it was due for a run.

Battling it out on a few, D304 Cobb at the top of the list, M110 Wagner behind it, T213 Lajoie among others - ended up the under bidder on all of the above. Landed the W600 Clarke (for what I thought was one of the best deals in the auction) and the Lionel Carter Wilson group of 16, kinda wish I went a little stronger for the others. Some of the hammer prices were staggering - though not unexpected in the current market. There were some super quality cards in this one.

[BRoberts]

Originally Posted by hcv123

Battling it out on a few, D304 Cobb at the top of the list, M110 Wagner behind it, T213 Lajoie among others - ended up the under bidder on all of the above. Landed the W600 Clarke (for what I thought was one of the best deals in the auction) and the Lionel Carter Wilson group of 16, kinda wish I went a little stronger for the others. Some of the hammer prices were staggering - though not unexpected in the current market. There were some super quality cards in this one.

I was watching Lionel Carter's Wilson Franks set because I remember when REA sold it not long ago (intact, as a complete set, in Spring 2020). It sold then for $14,400, and I was mad at myself for not having made a placeholder bid.

Last night, broken up into five lots, it sold for $34,740. Quite a return for a two-year hold.

[molenick]

Originally Posted by hcv123

Landed the W600 Clarke (for what I thought was one of the best deals in the auction) and the Lionel Carter Wilson group of 16, kinda wish I went a little stronger for the others.

Congrats on the Lionel Carter Wilson pickup. I didn't see them in person, but hovering over the cards on the scans, every card looks beautiful and undergraded.

[parkplace33]

Originally Posted by fkm_bky

Am I in the minority that thinks the partial Wagner going for $1.8m+ was really surprising? I mean, these days nothing should surprise me, but damn…that’s a hefty sum for 2/3 of a card.

I was after a few lower end Gehrigs, but happily was out bid.

Bill

Concur about the Wagner.

[darwinbulldog]

Didn't win anything I was really hoping for, but I did pick up both of the Walter Payton rookie cards with my "I can't let someone else get a good deal on these" bids.

[BobC]

Originally Posted by darwinbulldog

Didn't win anything I was really hoping for, but I did pick up both of the Walter Payton rookie cards with my "I can't let someone else get a good deal on these" bids.

Glenn,

I think you just touched on one of the biggest differences between collectors and investors, and modern versus vintage collectors, and a primary reason why if/when there ever is a correction to the card hobby market it seems to invariably have a much less drastic negative impact on the vintage (especially pre-war) side of the market.

As you so aptly noted, a collector realizes the intrinsic value of vintage cards, and often will not hesitate to pick up more and more copies of the same or similar cards if the price is right, basically setting a floor value wise for them. Modern collectors/investors seem to be more into just the money aspect, without anywhere near the same connection and attraction to the cards and players themselves. When they see a certain modern player or type of card issue's value tanking, they're more likely to get out, and stay out. And if the dropping market is profound enough, they may even get out of cards entirely and look to other things to now invest in. An actual collector at heart is much more unlikely to ever completely abandon their cards and collections.

[Aaron Seefeldt]

Was active on D304 Cobb General Baking, just couldn’t pull the trigger again…

[Rhotchkiss]

Pete, great pick up.

Aaron, I love that Successful Farming - so tough.

Congrats to all on some great pick ups

[molenick]

Yeah, I think you are right about T208/D359 based on how many times I remember seeing them up for sale (and the prices realized).

In other observations, it seems like Nap Lajoie is much more in demand than Eddie Collins. For two players of roughly equal ranking (and if anything, Collins is ranked a little higher), Lajoie seems to command higher prices when there are two cards from the same set and grade up for sale. Maybe there were other factors affecting the lots I was looking at and maybe it was just an anomaly for this auction.

Also, while there may be some SGC/PSA difference when it comes to rare type cards and stars, it is very noticeable when it comes to commons from widely collected sets. If you want a tough E card or a Ruth/Gehrig/Cobb/Robinson etc. you mostly just want that card for itself. But you usually want a Goudey/Leaf/Topps common because you are building a set...and the PSA set registry is a very powerful influence. (I guess I am just stating the obvious here.)

[timzcardz]

Nevermind

[molenick]

I am not sure why I am being quoted. There is a reference to ET3 and KD2 but nothing about T208 or D359

[Leon]

Originally Posted by molenick

I am not sure why I am being quoted. There is a reference to ET3 and KD2 but nothing about T208 or D359

That was a troll who had 4 posts and they have all been deleted and the troll banned.