Any interest in piggybacking a $50 sub??? CLOSED - Grades POSTED!! 6/20/22

[bigfanNY]

Bobby any room I have 1.

Jonathan

[bobbyw8469]

Jonathan, I think that was it.

[JollyElm]

***OPINIONS WANTED...EVEN POINTLESS, NOT WELL THOUGHT OUT ONES***

I have three slots for Bobby's submission. One 'should' be taken up by cracking out my PSA 8 ST 1968 Willie Mays and wiping away the schmutz, so that leaves two slots to fill. As a little insight, I'm not planning on selling anything, but it really is all about value, because the way this last year has went, I am never more than 5 minutes away from having to sell everything.

Here are my candidates:

1956 'Hammerin' Hank' - WYSIWYG. Overall pretty decent, but the corners are bumpity.

1972 'Dr. J.' Rookie - Crap! Knew the top left corner was bumped, but just realized the lower left corner has a light crease...so it's low grade. Ugh!!

1980 'The Great One' - really sweet overall, but is the top to bottom centering a killjoy??

1968 Johnny Bench Rookie - it looks awesome, but man, when you examine the scans, things pop up. A real tough call.

Two 1971 Munsons, One Plate - either fits nicely into anyone's complete set, but would one of them grade high enough to make the $50 to PSA a good move?




Edited to add:

Creasius Erving...

IMG_4210.jpg


Feel free to chime in, please.

[BobbyStrawberry]

Originally Posted by JollyElm

***OPINIONS WANTED...EVEN POINTLESS, NOT WELL THOUGHT OUT ONES***

Feel free to chime in, please.

Pointless and not well thought opinion - grade the Hank, Dr. J and Bench because those are my three favorite cards from the group

[bobbyw8469]

Aaron is around $400 (4....maybe a '5' on a good day)

Erving is around $500 (3)

Bench is around $300 (5)...I know...I'm harsh on these.

Even if the Munson's grade 6's, they are only around $300 cards...

They are all GREAT cards.....are they $50 grading fee great????

That's for you to decide.......if I didn't have much in it, I would grade the Erving......basketball is hot.

[Casey2296]

Grade the Munsons cuz 71 Topps look horrible in SGC holders.

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by Casey2296

Grade the Munsons cuz 71 Topps look horrible in SGC holders.

They won't be higher than 6's.....yes grade them....but not at $50 per.

[JollyElm]

One final contestant (the very top is actually a shadow, not the black of the card)...

1971rose100.jpg