Old Holders

[3-2-count]

Originally Posted by LincolnVT

That may be the case (pun intended), but I still think that the color, surface, registration and centering on the old SGC 5 Jackie outshines many of the same card and issue that I have seen recently in new PSA and SGC 5 holders. Just my opinion.

Agreed! Gorgeous card Ethan.

Contrary to what others believe, I say your Jackie gets a 5 with Psa as well if submitted today.

[ullmandds]

no question its a nice JR ethan...grading is subjective.

[3-2-count]

Pete, what do your black circles represent? The toning on the borders?

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by 3-2-count

Pete, what do your black circles represent? The toning on the borders?

some kind of print defect/registration issue...as compared to other examples i've viewed.

sorry for the confusion pic was deleted...I was mistaken.

[ullmandds]

comments deleted.

[3-2-count]

I see what you're talking about now, but there are actually a few different variations of this card.

I've seen many which have this same trait where Jackie's shoulder lines don't extend into the borders on each side.

Its not uncommon.

[steve B]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

well it seems the "line" on the rt side is present on all examples...i thought this was some kind of print defect...the left is just slightly off register...nothing to see here!!!

It's not off register. That card comes with those lines or without, as do most 49 Leaf cards that have portraits or bats near the border.

[steve B]

[Leon]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

no question its a nice JR ethan...but I venture to say its graded accurately...in light it may even warrant a qualifier?

Great looking, Jackie!

And this one is so nice it could have gone a grade higher, imo. The paper loss on back isn't that bad...(says the guy who owns it)

[LincolnVT]

I love it when someone posts a card and another person calls it out, draws all over it then does some research before saying “nothing to see here.” Sure makes a beautiful card look really ugly.

[uniship]

Regardless of the specific topic - that 48 leaf Jackie is straight FIRE!!

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by LincolnVT

I love it when someone posts a card and another person calls it out, draws all over it then does some research before saying “nothing to see here.” Sure makes a beautiful card look really ugly.

I kinda admitted I was wrong? I can delete my posts if you prefer Ethan? I was merely trying to help justify your assigned grade.

Kudos for posting a card!

[LincolnVT]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

I kinda admitted I was wrong? I can delete my posts if you prefer Ethan? I was merely trying to help justify your assigned grade.

Kudos for posting a card!

I appreciate this Pete. We all get a bit over zealous when we have something to say. I would just caution people about drawing on other peoples cards…we all have the technology now…

[brianp-beme]

If you ever meet up with Pete in person, make sure your graded cards and his black Sharpie never get too close.

Brian (I assume that is Pete's felt tip marker of choice)