FS 1947-48 well made pants jackie robinson - BGS AUTH - UNIQUE

[maniac_73]

It’s a post card not a rookie card


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Leon]

Originally Posted by maniac_73

It’s a post card not a rookie card


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

There is no rule that says a postcard can't be a rookie card, that I am aware of.

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by Leon

There is no rule that says a postcard can't be a rookie card, that I am aware of.

I agree that postcards are often considered Rookie Cards. Think of 1907 Dietsche TY COBB postcards and the likes that are advertised and sold on Auction Houses and it is called one of Cobbs Rookie card

[maniac_73]

Originally Posted by mrreality68

I agree that postcards are often considered Rookie Cards. Think of 1907 Dietsche TY COBB postcards and the likes that are advertised and sold on Auction Houses and it is called one of Cobbs Rookie card

Im of the mind that postcards are separate from regular cards and technically shouldn't be called rookies as much as a photo can be a called a rookie. But I'm also aware that its just my opinion and the whole idea of RC has become clouded in recent years so to each their own lol.

[Snapolit1]

If this card appeared today out of nowhere people would be salivating over it. Instead we've been bludgeoned with it seemingly for years, and it hasn't sold. It's like the house in your neighborhood that has been on sale forever for some odd reason. Most peculiar.

[bums1953]

one has to wonder why u are so worried about whether my card sells. i'm not worried. have u got nothing better to do? i'll sell it when i put it in the BIG auction of my choice and it gets my price. just like any NORMAL person - they sell their items when they get their price. maybe u do, but i don't worry about a one of a kind jackie card. enjoy talking about it because you'll never see another one.

[Carter08]

Possibly true, but I feel like I will see this one again and then I’ll be yelled at for buying a Mike Trout refractor (I would never buy) instead of this.

[Republicaninmass]

Originally Posted by maniac_73

Im of the mind that postcards are separate from regular cards and technically shouldn't be called rookies as much as a photo can be a called a rookie. But I'm also aware that its just my opinion and the whole idea of RC has become clouded in recent years so to each their own lol.

If one had a sonogram of a player, they would call it a rookie card.