T206 "Magie" Error Prices

[Rhotchkiss]

A PSA 2 with paper loss on the eye sold in PWCC last night for $19.2k ($16k before BP). That is a very healthy price, especially considering the facial paper loss. This confirms the value of a very pretty Magie PSA 2 that sold for $20.4k in May of 2021. $20k for a PSA 2 is very strong compared to historic.

[Mjpadilla84]

Here is my Magie Authentic, might have overpaid a bit at 17K last year but it has some nice eye appeal.

[Tao_Moko]

Originally Posted by Mjpadilla84

Here is my Magie Authentic, might have overpaid a bit at 17K last year but it has some nice eye appeal.

This presents very well. In my 20 card sheets would just look diamond cut.

[investinrookies]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

A PSA 2 with paper loss on the eye sold in PWCC last night for $19.2k ($16k before BP). That is a very healthy price, especially considering the facial paper loss. This confirms the value of a very pretty Magie PSA 2 that sold for $20.4k in May of 2021. $20k for a PSA 2 is very strong compared to historic.

Do you think that was paper loss over the eye, its hard to tell? Either way, clearly shows prices are now rising on this card. Might be a strong price for PSA 2, but in the big picture of things is it really?

[Pat R]

Originally Posted by investinrookies

Do you think that was paper loss over the eye, its hard to tell? Either way, clearly shows prices are now rising on this card. Might be a strong price for PSA 2, but in the big picture of things is it really?

It looks like paper addition to me.

[investinrookies]

Originally Posted by Pat R

It looks like paper addition to me.

Agree, it almost looks like a tiny ball of paper/debris stuck to the surface. If that’s the case it could be broken out of the holder and possibly wiped off which would dramatically improve the eye appeal of that one. Maybe that’s what the higher bidders were thinking as well?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Schlesinj]

Sold 11,302.88 SGC 1

[investinrookies]

Originally Posted by Schlesinj

Sold 11,302.88 SGC 1

ok "1" at best, price probably would of been higher with better eye appeal but still a strong price. The PSA 3 in heritage now over 37k.

[chriskim]

Don't forget Lelands has a Magie + Plank + rest of the set in their auction right now. Just buy the lot and keep the Magie... LOL

In fact, i would be interested in knowing the reserve. Probably half $Mil.