T206 "Magie" Error Prices

[puckpaul]

Originally Posted by investinrookies

enjoy reading everyone opinions and insight. I was inclined to ask this question because when I look at VCP prices it appears prices on this card have not risen like some others or to the degree of other more popular mainstream cards, depending on the grade. Definitely a great key card to own, but maybe the fact that "Magee" is not a HOFer and it being an "error" card limits its upside potential or maybe its over-looked?

Seems reasonable, though as I mentioned earlier, on the PSA pop charts, only 7 out of 112 are above a 4 vg-ex. So not many high end specimens exist and have traded. Many of the recent auctions are graded 1 to 3. Might need increasing prices of higher end specimens to pull up the lesser graded (and more numerous) ones more?

[investinrookies]

Originally Posted by puckpaul

Seems reasonable, though as I mentioned earlier, on the PSA pop charts, only 7 out of 112 are above a 4 vg-ex. So not many high end specimens exist and have traded. Many of the recent auctions are graded 1 to 3. Might need increasing prices if higher end specimens to pull up the more common ones?

That’s an interesting point and makes a lot of since. I didn’t realize it was so rare in higher grades. Wonder how that compares to the plank for example?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Rhotchkiss]

There is a decent looking 3 in heritage, currently sitting at $24k. Let’s see how that shakes out. I bought my psa 3 over 5 years ago for just over $21k. I paid a record at the time bc it is a great looking example. If/when I ever go to sell it, I will absolutely make my money back and I almost certainly will make money. To me, that’s all I can really ask for in a card - minimal downside with real upside potential, and I think the Magie error fits that billing well

[Yoda]

I could use a bit of the vault of T206 knowledge that exists here. I hold a Bud Sharpe with 2 rr's marked as a variation by SGC. I also have the single r base card. If the double r was printed first and then corrected with the single r edition, wouldn't this be akin to what happened with the Magee card? The Sharpe double r hardly gets the same attention or prices that Magie fetches.

[Pat R]

Originally Posted by Yoda

I could use a bit of the vault of T206 knowledge that exists here. I hold a Bud Sharpe with 2 rr's marked as a variation by SGC. I also have the single r base card. If the double r was printed first and then corrected with the single r edition, wouldn't this be akin to what happened with the Magee card? The Sharpe double r hardly gets the same attention or prices that Magie fetches.

You mean 2 P's don't you John?

[Yoda]

I did indeed mean 2 pp's. I blame lack of a 2nd cup of coffee this morning and not senility. Thanks for bringing it to my attention.

[53toppscollector]

An SGC 1 Magie just hit ebay with an opening bid of $5000, fwiw

https://www.ebay.com/itm/334297423875

[53toppscollector]

Originally Posted by investinrookies

That’s an interesting point and makes a lot of since. I didn’t realize it was so rare in higher grades. Wonder how that compares to the plank for example?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

here is the combined PSA and SGC pop report

There are a total of 214 Magie's graded between PSA and SGC (and likely less, because a few of those are probably crossovers) and 115 Planks.

Of those, 15% of the Magies are either a 4 or higher, while 24% of the Planks are 4 or higher.

47% of the Magies are either an A, 1, 1.5 or 2, compared to 56% of the Planks.

The most common grade for the Plank is an A (25 out of 115, or 22%) and the most common grade for the Magie is a 1 (64 out of 214, or 30%)

[investinrookies]

Originally Posted by 53toppscollector

here is the combined PSA and SGC pop report

There are a total of 214 Magie's graded between PSA and SGC (and likely less, because a few of those are probably crossovers) and 115 Planks.

Of those, 15% of the Magies are either a 4 or higher, while 24% of the Planks are 4 or higher.

47% of the Magies are either an A, 1, 1.5 or 2, compared to 56% of the Planks.

The most common grade for the Plank is an A (25 out of 115, or 22%) and the most common grade for the Magie is a 1 (64 out of 214, or 30%)

Anyone else notice the drop on the PSA pop report for T206s? The Magie error is now showing only 95.

[pawpawdiv9]

Hneuman is selling his 4th and final Magie sgc1 today. Almost at its peak compared to the other sale he had.

Warning!!!! Despite his past pics of sales are being used/hacked on 3 other listings with hacked/scammer accounts --as mentioned in other threads here.

[investinrookies]

Originally Posted by pawpawdiv9

Hneuman is selling his 4th and final Magie sgc1 today. Almost at its peak compared to the other sale he had.

Warning!!!! Despite his past pics of sales are being used/hacked on 3 other listings with hacked/scammer accounts --as mentioned in other threads here.

That was a really nice SGC 1, $12858 was stronger than the previous SGC 1 that sold just a couple weeks before. Anyone else see the PSA 2.5 that allegedly sold for $37500? It was a nice example as well.

[Yoda]

I need some help from one of our T206 gurus. As I mentioned previously, I hold a Bud Sharpe two pp's error card, as stated on the SGC flip. Is this really any different than the far more known and expensive Magee-ie error, as in when ATC saw the original two pp's error had been issued, it was quickly pulled to correct things with the standard one p. card. I have no idea what the pop count is between the cards. Has the market ignored this rarity or do I have things wrong?