1951 Topps Red Back Pack Opening

[toppcat]

Originally Posted by Volod

Not sure if this is off topic, but the YouTube video that auto-followed the '51 Red Back pack featured a couple of guys opening a modern slickly packaged box of eight 1955 Bowman cards priced at forty bucks. Strongly implied that the cards were randomly inserted, but, hey, the first seven maybe so, even though two umps and five commons, albeit in excellent to near mint condition. The eighth randomly selected card was a mostly mint Mays with a slight stain on the back...hmm. I wonder if the guys in the video were somehow involved in the sales of the forty buck lots?

A mid-series Mays and high number umps in the same pack? Fake all the way, vintage or not.

[Volod]

Originally Posted by toppcat

A mid-series Mays and high number umps in the same pack? Fake all the way, vintage or not.

Right, Dave, but if you watch the video, these guys are opening a recently boxed lot, not a pack from 1955. And I didn't even consider the cards' legitimacy. Apparently, the eight card lot is one of forty lots selling at 100 bucks each. The forty lots would make up a complete broken set for a total of four grand. The box opening they post to YouTube naturally contains the juiciest haul - the two umps and the Mays kicker, all in EX - MT condition. I just wonder how many naive viewers would invest a hundred bucks for a lot after watching these guys pull a Mays out of one. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jbT-U-Us9-I

[Georj]

Aren't the two cards supposed to be attached where the perforations are?

[toppcat]

Originally Posted by Georj

Aren't the two cards supposed to be attached where the perforations are?

Seemingly only in the 1951 5 and 10 cent packs, as the 52 Doubles reissue is just two cards. I can't say I've heard of them being attached in the 52 packs but it's possible. Some Blue Back Doubles packs also exist.

[toppcat]

Originally Posted by Volod

Right, Dave, but if you watch the video, these guys are opening a recently boxed lot, not a pack from 1955. And I didn't even consider the cards' legitimacy. Apparently, the eight card lot is one of forty lots selling at 100 bucks each. The forty lots would make up a complete broken set for a total of four grand. The box opening they post to YouTube naturally contains the juiciest haul - the two umps and the Mays kicker, all in EX - MT condition. I just wonder how many naive viewers would invest a hundred bucks for a lot after watching these guys pull a Mays out of one. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jbT-U-Us9-I

I hear ya.

I only realized that after my initial post and then I edited it, simultaneously making it easier and harder to understand at the same time - d'oh! Scam city on these it seems.