One Cy Young to have in your collection, budget of $2500 - which one and why??

[Belfast1933]

Would love advice on adding Cy Young to my HOF collection - just lost out last night on an E90-1 Young… that is my lead card but since I now have time, wonder what other collectors advice would be.

My general parameters are:

- from his playing days
- prefer as a Boston American/Red Sox (but a bit flexy there)
- rarity does not matter to much to me (ie, rare backs, etc)
- looks like him (so many cards look like anyone other than ol’ Denton!)
- cool look (like the sharp red background on the E-90-1
- low grade is fine but eye appeal and cemeteries matter a lot
- budget is up to $2500

Appreciate visuals of your faves from your collection (or your own Cy Young quest!)

Thx

Jeff

[3-2-count]

Other than the E90-1 which is a fantastic card, either one of these would be my choice and nice lower grade examples can be found within that price range if you're patient. Good luck!

Here is my pair that I chose!

[sportscardpete]

Agreed with the above, t206 portrait in a 1.5-2 range, they are timeless.

[Rhotchkiss]

I would go for a card with his most iconic image from earlier days (same as e107 and w600), which is E90-1, t206 portrait or m116.

I put e94, two t206 pitching poses, and t205, after that. Personally, I think the e92 Young cards are super ugly. The e98 is not even him, and e93 has him with a bat. I would not go for these, although they may be most affordable

[Leon]

I like a lot of the T cards and some of the E's of Cy....

[Jcosta19]

I agree with most of the above responses.
I don't have one to show but I think the M116 is probably the best value as far as great classic image and price right now.

Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk

[Bpm0014]

Make sure you don’t get Irv Young!

[Cmount76]

E90-1 and M116 would be my top 2, hands down.

A couple of years ago, I was roaming through the White Plains Show, and a guy I deal with regularly showed me this... I loved it and had to have it.

[packs]

Just took the plunge myself:

[Belfast1933]

Originally Posted by Cmount76

E90-1 and M116 would be my top 2, hands down.

A couple of years ago, I was roaming through the White Plains Show, and a guy I deal with regularly showed me this... I loved it and had to have it.

I’ve seen that image before… love it. What is the card? It’s hard to see the card name/series

Thx for sharing.

[Cmount76]

Originally Posted by Belfast1933

I’ve seen that image before… love it. What is the card? It’s hard to see the card name/series

Thx for sharing.

1908 A.C. Williams postcard - and to me, the selling point was the caption...

[vthobby]

Iconic and affordable T205 Gold Border all day!

Good luck!

Mike

[Steve D]

Originally Posted by Belfast1933

Would love advice on adding Cy Young to my HOF collection - just lost out last night on an E90-1 Young… that is my lead card but since I now have time, wonder what other collectors advice would be.

My general parameters are:

- from his playing days
- prefer as a Boston American/Red Sox (but a bit flexy there)
- rarity does not matter to much to me (ie, rare backs, etc)
- looks like him (so many cards look like anyone other than ol’ Denton!)
- cool look (like the sharp red background on the E-90-1
- low grade is fine but eye appeal and cemeteries matter a lot
- budget is up to $2500

Appreciate visuals of your faves from your collection (or your own Cy Young quest!)

Thx

Jeff

I'm just wondering, what do cemeteries have to do with it?

Steve

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by vtgmsc

Iconic and affordable T205 Gold Border all day!

Good luck!

Mike

+1 agreeing with the T205 Gold border

[Piratedogcardshows]

I wouldn't mind a T206 Old Mill Portrait if you ever came my way!

[MVSNYC]

Leon, this is still in good hands, in my collection.

Jeff, although not a Boston jersey, I definitely think this T206 portrait, is one to have.

[Belfast1933]

Originally Posted by Steve D

I'm just wondering, what do cemeteries have to do with it?

Steve

That was my Easter egg to see who was REALLY paying attention. Steve, for the win! (Damn autocorrect… in a work text recently I referred to our entire senior team as the “senile” team. I think Siri was messin with me)

[Exhibitman]

Originally Posted by Belfast1933

That was my Easter egg to see who was REALLY paying attention. Steve, for the win! (Damn autocorrect… in a work text recently I referred to our entire senior team as the “senile” team. I think Siri was messin with me)

You should see my autocorrect. I do stand-up and some of my corrections take it in a very bad direction. I recently had to email someone named "Cyntia"; u can imagine what my autocorrect made it.

[Yoda]

I wonder when the last time a Cy Just So RC appeared on the market? Probably fetch a tad more than $2,500 today.

[rats60]

Originally Posted by mrreality68

+1 agreeing with the T205 Gold border

+2 The t205 would my choice with the t3 as a second choice.

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by Yoda

I wonder when the last time a Cy Just So RC appeared on the market? Probably fetch a tad more than $2,500 today.

you mean the last time "THE" just co cy young appeared on the market?

I'm partial to the e90-1 boston portrait myself...and I also have an e93 cy young in my collection.

Cant go wrong with any of the portraits either!

[Leon]

Originally Posted by MVSNYC

Leon, this is still in good hands, in my collection.

Jeff, although not a Boston jersey, I definitely think this T206 portrait, is one to have.

Great card.

[fkm_bky]

T206 Portrait. I collect T206 HOF Portraits, and it’s the classics image of him.

Bill

I like mine

[vthobby]

Originally Posted by MVSNYC

Leon, this is still in good hands, in my collection.

Jeff, although not a Boston jersey, I definitely think this T206 portrait, is one to have.

BEAUTIFUL Hindu! Wow!

Could not be in better hands!



Peace, Mike

[Jcosta19]

Originally Posted by Jason

I wouldn't mind a T206 Old Mill Portrait if you ever came my way!

One of my favorites as well.



Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk

[DeanH3]

I echo Tony's recommendation. T206 Portrait or T205 would be my choice.

Not a nice as Michael's Hindu. But here is one you don't see often. Wanted to add, that's a fantastic OM Justin. Very nice!

[Belfast1933]

Thx for all of the advice… nice options here. I ended up making a nice pick up from a fellow Net54er.

See below - thanks again, all!

[Jcosta19]

Originally Posted by DeanH3

I echo Tony's recommendation. T206 Portrait or T205 would be my choice.

Not a nice as Michael's Hindu. But here is one you don't see often. Wanted to add, that's a fantastic OM Justin. Very nice!

Originally Posted by Belfast1933

Thx for all of the advice… nice options here. I ended up making a nice pick up from a fellow Net54er.

See below - thanks again, all!

Great pick up, congrats.

And thanks Dean, that's a gorgeous EPDG.

Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk

[MVSNYC]

Thanks guys (re: the kind words on the Cy Hindu).

Some outstanding cards in this thread. Dean, I love that EPDG! Justin, the Old Mill is stunning!

And Jeff, great choice, congrats!

[Oscar_Stanage]

resurrecting this thread in advance of the National.....

I am familiar with T206 prices. However, a friend of mine really wants a Cy Young tobacco card and I am certain that any T206 will be out of budget.

Is it even possible to get a Cy Young tobacco card (1 or A) for under $1200? I am not familiar with anything outside of T206.

[Luke]

Bare hands and gloves shows Auth or 1 should be doable for $1200 or less.

[Alaskanmade]

Look for his T205 card.
under 1,200 for a 1 or A should be possible.
And its a gorgeous card (here is my 2).

[ullmandds]

I’ve got the E 90–1 Boston… I love this image! The E 93 is interesting because it depicts him batting… but my next favorite would probably be the green tea 206 portrait

[Oscar_Stanage]

thanks for the replies !
On 6/30 a PSA1 t205 went for $1700.

[x2drich2000]

Originally Posted by Oscar_Stanage

resurrecting this thread in advance of the National.....

I am familiar with T206 prices. However, a friend of mine really wants a Cy Young tobacco card and I am certain that any T206 will be out of budget.

Is it even possible to get a Cy Young tobacco card (1 or A) for under $1200? I am not familiar with anything outside of T206.

As others have said, T205 is possible, but will be beat up and might be hard to find (June REA had 2 SGC 1.5s - one sold for $1500 the other $1170, a CSG 1 sold on Ebay in early June for $1k). T202 is definitely possible - an SGC 5 sold in June on Ebay for $1400.

If he is referring to "tobacco card" in a general sense (i.e. playing days) rather than technically, a few other options open up. E93, Fan Craze, E101, etc would be options that might be close to that price point but I haven't seen low grade sales of them recently.

[Rad_Hazard]

Really any Cy from his playing days for under 2k is a great deal. I was able to snag this 1.5 Old Mill for sub-2k. I like this better than the portrait since it's an "action" pose.