The Tobacco Triple Crown - Players in T205, T206 and T207 sets

[G1911]

My favorite triple crown is Quinn (already posted), because of his appearance in 1933 Goudey as an active major league player (unlike the Collins, Speaker and Lajoie). He's the only T205/6/7 run I've built intentionally and specifically.

Another cool one is Chief Bender, though I don't have his, because it can extend both ways. Bender appears also in T204 and t208, the only subject to appear in 5 consecutive T card sets by the ACC numbers, I believe. I'd build his run if a T208 wasn't so expensive.

Paddy Livingston, a sentimantal favorite as his T205 was my first T card of any kind, also appeared in T208 to expand his run to 4 in a row. Numerous players in T204 extend to 4 as well.

Jack O'Brien, Jack Goodman, Leach Cross and Young Corbett hold the non-baseball consecutive T card set record at 3 (T218/T219/T220), going off memory. I don't believe any non-sport subject appears in 3 in a row T sets.

[wheatfan]

IMG_2299.jpg

Here's my Zack Wheat T206, 205, and 207.

Favorite thing is the stains on the Polar Bear from being packed in scrap tobacco. Also that they're Zack Wheat. Also that his first name appears three different ways...

I absolutely love the 1960 Fleer (HOF) card they did with him posed like his T205.

[brianp-beme]

Neat info about Bender and Livingstone. I didn't consider the T208 set because it is a fairly rare beast and only features members of the A's (nothing against the team, I swear). And although quite a bit more common than the T208 set, I decided against the T204 because of the differences in size and shape versus T205/T206/T207.

By the way, nice Wheats!

Brian

Originally Posted by G1911

My favorite triple crown is Quinn (already posted), because of his appearance in 1933 Goudey as an active major league player (unlike the Collins, Speaker and Lajoie). He's the only T205/6/7 run I've built intentionally and specifically.

Another cool one is Chief Bender, though I don't have his, because it can extend both ways. Bender appears also in T204 and t208, the only subject to appear in 5 consecutive T card sets by the ACC numbers, I believe. I'd build his run if a T208 wasn't so expensive.

Paddy Livingston, a sentimantal favorite as his T205 was my first T card of any kind, also appeared in T208 to expand his run to 4 in a row. Numerous players in T204 extend to 4 as well.

Jack O'Brien, Jack Goodman, Leach Cross and Young Corbett hold the non-baseball consecutive T card set record at 3 (T218/T219/T220), going off memory. I don't believe any non-sport subject appears in 3 in a row T sets.

[wheatfan]

Originally Posted by brianp-beme

neat info about bender and livingstone. I didn't consider the t208 set because it is a fairly rare beast and only features members of the a's (nothing against the team, i swear). And although quite a bit more common than the t208 set, i decided against the t204 because of the differences in size and shape versus t205/t206/t207.

By the way, nice wheats!

Brian

thanks!

[GeoPoto]

Gabby Street with T3 in lieu of T207, which reflects his defection to NY.

Charles E. "Gabby" Street. "The Old Sarge". Catcher for the Washington Senators in 1908-1911. 312 hits and 2 home runs in 8 MLB seasons. Debuted with the Cincinnati Reds in 1904.

Caught ball dropped from top of Washington Monument. Holds MLB record for longest gap between MLB games at 19 years -- 1912-1931. Managed the St. Louis Cardinals in 1929 and 1930-1933, including the 1931 World Series championship. Managed the St. Louis Browns in 1938.

Because Gabby was discarded by Washington (Griffith) after the 1911 season, his T207 card reflects his status in 1912 as a New York Highlander. That prevents me from being able to complete a Tobacco Triple Crown as Brian has defined it. But since nobody has rushed forward to cover Street, I offer a modified, but thoroughly collectable, Tobacco Triple Play with Street's T3 card replacing the T207. This also provides me another chance to present what I regard as one of the most beautiful (and thoughtful) tobacco cards ever created, the T3 depicting Gabby as a Washington Senator with our national capital and Washington monument looming in the cityscape.

From Street's SABR Biography: Persistence paid off for Street, and his contract was sold to the Washington Senators. Of the 504 games Street played in the major leagues, 429 were over the next four years (1908-11) with Washington. His calling card was his defense, as he led the league in putouts and double plays in both 1908 and 1909. In 1910 he was atop his peers with a fielding percentage of .978.

(I have to admit to not understanding what leading the league in double plays (on defense) means. Perhaps it refers to starting double plays, which could begin with poor sacrifice bunts or strikeouts on hit-and-run? Seems an odd record for a catcher. You would expect a shortstop.)

In today’s vernacular Street’s batting average would be characterized as worthy of the “Mendoza Line,” as his average with the Senators was a meek .210. Catchers of the day were never expected to hit that well, and in any event Washington was not fielding a championship team in those years, finishing no better than seventh place in the American League and no closer than 22½ games back of the pennant winner.

Importantly, Walter Johnson favored Street, acknowledging him as a first-rate catcher. “He always kept the pitcher in good spirits with his continual chatter of sense and nonsense,” said the Big Train. “ ‘Ease up on this fellow, Walter, he has a wife and two kids,’ he would call jokingly when some batter was hugging the plate and getting a toehold for a crack at one of my fast ones. ‘This fellow hasn’t had a hit off you since you joined the league,’ might be his next remark and so on throughout the game.”

https://www.net54baseball.com/attach...1&d=1622830256
https://www.net54baseball.com/attach...1&d=1622830266
https://www.net54baseball.com/attach...1&d=1622830274

[brianp-beme]

I believe there was a tie when it comes to Gabby Street's Tobacco Triple Crown, where his T3 and T207 cards were deadlocked due to the T3 visually depicting the Washington Monument on the front, while the T207 mentions the ball drop from the Washington Monument in the writeup on the back.

Brian