New BODA thread; PWCC selling previously outed cards now "reviewed by PSA"

[Rhotchkiss]

Troy, the CJ I posted (and will continue to post) is a major f-ck up by PSA. The card is a clear reprint, obvious on many levels. Not only did they grade it, they authenticated it! They gave a numeric grade to a obvious reprint. As someone said elsewhere, perhaps the grade is an “opinion” but the authentication part is not. PSA quickly took action and took this card out of circulation. They rectified nothing. Instead, they tried to cover their tracks. Luckily we have pictures.

[trambo]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

Troy, the CJ I posted (and will continue to post) is a major f-ck up by PSA. The card is a clear reprint, obvious on many levels. Not only did they grade it, they authenticated it! They gave a numeric grade to a obvious reprint. As someone said elsewhere, perhaps the grade is an “opinion” but the authentication part is not. PSA quickly took action and took this card out of circulation. They rectified nothing. Instead, they tried to cover their tracks. Luckily we have pictures.

Wasn't trying to call you (or anyone) out, Ryan, so my apologies if you took it that way. Just saw one card, looked up the cert and saw it wasn't there. That was it. So I posted that the cert wasn't there anymore and it appears in this instance PSA corrected the error. Whether it was a cover up or not is opinion. Not sure why they'd pick that card versus some of the others that they missed as doctored for this cover up, though.

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by trambo

Wasn't trying to call you (or anyone) out, Ryan, so my apologies if you took it that way. Just saw one card, looked up the cert and saw it wasn't there. That was it. So I posted that the cert wasn't there anymore and it appears in this instance PSA corrected the error. Whether it was a cover up or not is opinion. Not sure why they'd pick that card versus some of the others that they missed as doctored for this cover up, though.

because this mistake was as pathetic/embarrassing as a mistake can be...maybe?

[Rhotchkiss]

Originally Posted by trambo

Wasn't trying to call you (or anyone) out, Ryan, so my apologies if you took it that way. Just saw one card, looked up the cert and saw it wasn't there. That was it. So I posted that the cert wasn't there anymore and it appears in this instance PSA corrected the error. Whether it was a cover up or not is opinion. Not sure why they'd pick that card versus some of the others that they missed as doctored for this cover up, though.

No worries Troy. I took no offense! I am just clarifying that PSA had a colossal, negligent, and incompetent mess up on that particular card. I mean, it’s beyond comical how bad that one is/was