Should be interesting CSG 52 Topps Mays

[LincolnVT]

Just speaking from experience...maybe I overpaid, but I just spent over 8k on a decent PSA 1.5 Mays. Thinking a PSA 1 might land in the $6,500 area today.

Originally Posted by CobbSpikedMe

Here's a somewhat comparable PSA 1 that sold 03/07/21 for only $2,629. I'm not sure where your $6,500+ estimate is coming from Ethan.



.

[Republicaninmass]

Face creased 1 May's just sold for 4400 fwiw.

[robertsmithnocure]

Looks like a 1.5 to me. Everyone makes mistakes, but they obviously knew that they will be under the microscope with their first cards. I do not understand how they could have let that card out in that grade.

[D. Bergin]

[68Hawk]

Originally Posted by D. Bergin

Rosacea much?

[Rookiemonster]

Originally Posted by D. Bergin

A true origin story for PSA.

[perezfan]

Originally Posted by robertsmithnocure

Looks like a 1.5 to me. Everyone makes mistakes, but they obviously knew that they will be under the microscope with their first cards. I do not understand how they could have let that card out in that grade.

I agree it’s overgraded by PSA standards. But maybe they are going with a more equitable grading scale, and not trying to emulate PSA. Just theorizing.

[ullmandds]

It used to be...a few years ago...that at any given moment of any day...you could go on ebay and find goudey ruths...mantle rookies...t206 cobb...they've all dried up...and noones selling.

The 52 topps mays has had quite a run lately...So why are there sooo many for sale right now on ebay...there are tons!!!!! I get that many are taking profits...but...isn't this. card that should bridge the gap with mantle as time goes by? Do people NOT want to hold this card?

[chadeast]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

It used to be...a few years ago...that at any given moment of any day...you could go on ebay and find goudey ruths...mantle rookies...t206 cobb...they've all dried up...and noones selling.

The 52 topps mantle has had quite a run lately...So why are there sooo many for sale right now on ebay...there are tons!!!!! I get that many are taking profits...but...isn't this. card that should bridge the gap with mantle as time goes by? Do people NOT want to hold this card?

I have a guess. This card, perhaps more so than the others you mentioned, has been purchased over the years as an investment by some, and not necessarily as a collectible (little emotional attachment to the card). So some of those who purchased it as an investment now see this as the time to cash out on that investment.

Obviously not the majority, but if, say 10% of t206 Cobb buyers purchase purely as an investment, while 30% of Mantle 311 buyers do the same, there would be many more Mantles up for sale when the market rises dramatically, as it has now. Again, just a guess.

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by chadeast

I have a guess. This card, perhaps more so than the others you mentioned, has been purchased over the years as an investment by some, and not necessarily as a collectible (little emotional attachment to the card). So some of those who purchased it as an investment now see this as the time to cash out on that investment.

Obviously not the majority, but if, say 10% of t206 Cobb buyers purchase purely as an investment, while 30% of Mantle 311 buyers do the same, there would be many more Mantles up for sale when the market rises dramatically, as it has now. Again, just a guess.

oops...I meant mays!!!!

[Fuddjcal]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

It used to be...a few years ago...that at any given moment of any day...you could go on ebay and find goudey ruths...mantle rookies...t206 cobb...they've all dried up...and noones selling.

The 52 topps mays has had quite a run lately...So why are there sooo many for sale right now on ebay...there are tons!!!!! I get that many are taking profits...but...isn't this. card that should bridge the gap with mantle as time goes by? Do people NOT want to hold this card?

I do, unfortunately, It's not a PSA so no one would want it anyway. It's a very trimmable & soakable PSA 7, so maybe send it off to PWCC for a shill bidding war?

I'm not liking the CSG 2.5 Mays much. The card or the holder.

[perezfan]

Originally Posted by Fuddjcal

I do, unfortunately, It's not a PSA so no one would want it anyway. It's a very trimmable & soakable PSA 7, so maybe send it off to PWCC for a shill bidding war?

I'm not liking the CSG 2.5 Mays much. The card or the holder.

That card looks soooooo much better in the SGC holder. Very classy and hope it never ends up trimmed and in a PSA slab.

The new grading company really needs to pay attention to the near-unanimous comments here, and address their aesthetics for vintage cards.

[zoomfest]

Well, looks like the masses have spoken and we have an answer - no bids. In a world of increasingly crazy prices, looks like sanity prevailed for a moment.

[chadeast]

Originally Posted by zoomfest

Well, looks like the masses have spoken and we have an answer - no bids. In a world of increasingly crazy prices, looks like sanity prevailed for a moment.

And yet, sanity has left the building once again. Listed for $6,999.00 now, with the Make Offer active. Sure, why not?!?

https://www.ebay.com/itm/27473143813...m=274731438139

[Rookiemonster]

If you get that mantle regraded you’ll probably get a CSG 4.5

[pawpawdiv9]

Originally Posted by chadeast

And yet, sanity has left the building once again. Listed for $6,999.00 now, with the Make Offer active. Sure, why not?!?

https://www.ebay.com/itm/27473143813...m=274731438139

Compare it to the Psa 2.5 (Probstein) currently has @ 5600 (1 day left)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/1952-Topps-...MAAOSwbs5gU4ek

[Tao_Moko]

I'm no slabber, but I don't have as big of an issue with the 2.5 grade. That's saying it is 75% less than perfect. A "1" can be a wide range of ugly far worse than this card. No 100+ year old card looks good in a plastic slab with a hologrammed flip and barcode to me. Like comparing a turd to a booger.

[irv]

https://www.ebay.com/itm/38404428170...222508&mkevt=1

[Tao_Moko]

Originally Posted by irv

https://www.ebay.com/itm/38404428170...222508&mkevt=1

That puts it in better perspective. If all 2.5's looked the same it would be nice. The CSG is the turd in this battle.

[dio]

My 2.5 SGC comparison